Do you think Duran top 10 P4P list???

[morancito]

The point is, top 10 p4p are those guys who have impeccable slates and their victories resulted in unquestionable conquests.

A guy who loses to just about every nemesis he had in his career is not deserving of that spot.

Duran is HOF no doubt, but people here are a bit delusional if they think a guy who loses to a Hagler, get KTFO by Hearns and humiliated by Ray deserves top10 p4p.

Willie Pep, widely considered the best Feather ever and a consensus top 3 p4p ever, lost 3 out of 4 times against Sandy Saddler, his main nemesis. Must I assume Pep isn't top 10 pfp ever?

[BBKing]

He's not top 10, he's top 5.

1. Ray Robinson

2. Henry Armstrong

3. Harry Greb

4. Sam Langford

5. Roberto Duran

[Chups]

He's not top 10, he's top 5.

1. Ray Robinson

2. Henry Armstrong

3. Harry Greb

4. Sam Langford

5. Roberto Duran

Ali, Frazier, Dempsey, Joe Louis and Johnson will spank your ass......LOL.

[GoldenBoy23]

He's not top 10, he's top 5.

1. Ray Robinson

2. Henry Armstrong

3. Harry Greb

4. Sam Langford

5. Roberto Duran

WTF no Ali?

[Chups]

Not to mention ...Whitaker, Leonard, Hagler.

[oldgringo]

Ali, Frazier, Dempsey, Joe Louis and Johnson will spank your ass......LOL.

Do you know what constitutes a p4p list?

[Chups]

Do you know what constitutes a p4p list?

Yes I do......What's your TOP 10 list?

[wmute]

He's not top 10, he's top 5.

1. Ray Robinson

2. Henry Armstrong

3. Harry Greb

4. Sam Langford

5. Roberto Duran

no joe gans?

[wmute]

Tyson at TOP 10? I don't think so! Who said this? JOM's?

yes, i think he has in general too many HWs in p4p, louis and ali are the only ones i would consider in a top p4p (maybe marciano because he was small). I see you too consider a lot of HWs, I think there is a problem in that heavyweights historically get the bigger news/media coverage, money, baddest-man-on the-planet-allure, by far,

but when compiling a p4p list this should not be considered.

I mean between sal sanchez and tyson I would not think for a second on who's better...

there are many great fighers from lower weight classes

barney ross
jimmy wilde
willie pep
joe gans
eder jofre
...

these are the ones that MIGHT keep duran out of the top 10, along the ones bbking mentioned, not george foreman

your mentioning of whitaker is also a good point of discussion

[JOM'S]

hey jom,

i ll start for mthe easiest one

you have tyson above duran p4p, tyson did not even rule 1 division for as long as duran, and he got outboxed, outbattled and KOed at his own weight

sorry bro this got mixed up, this is not my list of top 10, this is just something i dug up at google...

Tyson is on my top 10 heavyweights but he is not among my top 10 p4p ...