List your top 5 welterweights right now.

[_original_]

1. Mayweather
2. Bradley
3. Marquez
4. Pacquiao
5. Maidana

[John Locke]

Again it's all personal choice which is fine it just further proves my point that either Maidana, Thurman, Porter can be top 5.

For example going by resume Thurman's best win was against a though veteran in Soto-Karass whom Maidana already beat. His second best win against Chaves is not as good as beating Broner who was slightly more proven and at least the champ on paper. Quintana was also nowhere near his best so you can't rank that win over Maidana's win over Lopez who had his carter defining victory over Ortiz his last fight at WW.

Fair enough.

I disagree about Karass though, l think Chaves and Quintana are better wins. I would also pick Chaves to beat Broner, seeing as he's a big puncher and we saw what Maidana done to Broner, so...

Anyway, all of you lot will be on the Thurman bandwagon soon enough . The guy is a special fighter.

[Nights King]

A top 5 doesnt mean all 5 are good.

Your top 5???

[Fetta]

When in the bloody hell did I say he's not on my list?

If I said Pac is #2, that obviously means Floyd's #1, unless there's some imaginary fighter out there that I think is better than Floyd and Pac.

When in the bloody hell did i say he wasnt on your list

[puga]

floyd
timmy
maidana
porter
jmm
pac

H2H at the moment , thurman @ number 2 behind floyd imo...

[sugarsmosley]

1-floyd
2-bradley
3-jmm
4-maidiana
5-porter


cant really rank manny at ww cause he really doesnt even fight ww's..if he beats bradley in April he should be #2

not even pac at 5 lol, yet you put his sparring partner with 1 big win in. i dont see how someone could say porter > pacquiao even at this point

[_original_]

It's ridiculous having Pacquiao at number 2, especially above guys that beat him.

Ok, you'll say Bradley got a gift, fair enough but Marquez did knock Manny the hell out and Bradley beat Marquez, thus those guys need to be ranked above him. It's just common sense. You can't have him at the number two slot for beating an unranked Rios coming off a loss.

[BUNGALOWS]

When in the bloody hell did i say he wasnt on your list

YOu going to get on Keith who just listed his top 5 and Floyds not even on it?

Is English your first language?

[Chrismart]

Mayweather
Pacquiao
Bradley
Marquez
Maidana

[MPX309]

Based on last performance

Thurman
Bradley
Floyd
Maidana
Pac