List your top 5 welterweights right now.

[Fetta]

it sounds more like your 5 favorite welterweights, instead of top 5. even GGG is more proven then thurman. GGG is actually a champ and is widely the unanimous 2nd best MW. thurman like GGG, is still untested but fights in a much better division, the money division aka WW.

to not have tim bradley in your top 5 WW's and being completely serious, sounds like too me prematurely discrediting a pacman victory.

for goodness sakes, most think timmy is #3 P4P, atleast we know OP is trolling. but uhhhh, it's your opinion and you're entitled to it..

Thats why i explained it in my original post cause this is the kind of responses i will get. I have said its a good fight but at the same time i remember hearing about how Bradley wasnt crap and he lost big and pac put him in wheelchair and so on and so on. I dont think highly of Bradley as some Pac fans once thought too. Only difference is i never stopped thinking that. Yes he beat JMM and that was a good win but i think JMM beats him if they fight again and i know pac will beat him so with those 3 my preference is to leave Bradley out.

YEs i know Bradley is thought of as 3 P4P but so was Nonito when i didnt think much of him and now where is he and those who pushed him as that high ranking. Just my opinion

[John Locke]

He sc****d by maidana and still runs from a rematch.



if anyone did any schooling.. Maidana just schooled Khan on how to get a Mayweather shot.

Sc****d? Barring a couple of rounds, Khan was pretty comfortable throughout.

[Fetta]

I have Pac 2, but I never said you HAVE to have Pac 2. I just think it's dumb to have JMM on the list, and leave off the guy that beat the guy that you regard in such high esteem.

So i dont have to have Pac as 2 but I have to have Bradley on list?

And once again how can you have a guy ranked higher than the guy that didnt just beat him but destroyed him.

Preference.

[BUNGALOWS]

Thats why i explained it in my original post cause this is the kind of responses i will get. I have said its a good fight but at the same time i remember hearing about how Bradley wasnt crap and he lost big and pac put him in wheelchair and so on and so on. I dont think highly of Bradley as some Pac fans once thought too. Only difference is i never stopped thinking that. Yes he beat JMM and that was a good win but i think JMM beats him if they fight again and i know pac will beat him so with those 3 my preference is to leave Bradley out.

YEs i know Bradley is thought of as 3 P4P but so was Nonito when i didnt think much of him and now where is he and those who pushed him as that high ranking. Just my opinion

I completely understand what you're saying here, but I think you've sniffed too much glue for not having him in your top 5, based off merit, at least.

You can think he sucks all you want, but to not even have him as a top 5 WW is asinine.

And Bradley is nothing like Donaire, where he doesn't know how to come forward, and he can't fight without counter punching. Bradley's skills have been on display time and time again.

[Nights King]

1)Mayweather 1)Victor Ortiz
2)Bradley 2)Andre Berto
3)Marquez 3)Adrien Broner
4)Pacquiao 4)Josesito Lopez
5)Porter/Thurman 5)Amir Khan

Oh yeah and take a second to highlight an alternate top 5.

[BUNGALOWS]

So i dont have to have Pac as 2 but I have to have Bradley on list?

And once again how can you have a guy ranked higher than the guy that didnt just beat him but destroyed him.

Preference.

Yes, preference, BUT, you had Thurman on there based on preference, AND he hasn't proven himself 1x where we can say he can hang with any of the top 5 WWs.

[sugarsmosley]

I completely understand what you're saying here, but I think you've sniffed too much glue for not having him in your top 5, based off merit, at least.

You can think he sucks all you want, but to not even have him as a top 5 WW is asinine.

And Bradley is nothing like Donaire, where he doesn't know how to come forward, and he can't fight without counter punching. Bradley's skills have been on display time and time again.

spot on.... bradley was nothing like donaire... i mean bradley's lone win over JMM trumps anything donaire has done period, let alone his big run in 2012.

i think bradley beats JMM anytime, and the pac fight is close but i have PACMAN winning a decision and getting the belt back

[Fetta]

I completely understand what you're saying here, but I think you've sniffed too much glue for not having him in your top 5, based off merit, at least.

You can think he sucks all you want, but to not even have him as a top 5 WW is asinine.

And Bradley is nothing like Donaire, where he doesn't know how to come forward, and he can't fight without counter punching. Bradley's skills have been on display time and time again.

Its not like im saying he the worse WW on the planet. Hes 6 on my list but this is top 5.

[jose.sooto]

The ****riding here is borderline ******! yes Thurman is good but putting him in the top 5 over someone like bradley ? get outta here , Keith has yet to be tested against a world class fighther , hes just 22 fights in smh

[Fetta]

spot on.... bradley was nothing like donaire... i mean bradley's lone win over JMM trumps anything donaire has done period, let alone his big run in 2012.

i think bradley beats JMM anytime, and the pac fight is close but i have PACMAN winning a decision and getting the belt back

Your missing the point about mentioning Nonito