List your top 5 welterweights right now.

[BUNGALOWS]

spot on.... bradley was nothing like donaire... i mean bradley's lone win over JMM trumps anything donaire has done period, let alone his big run in 2012.

i think bradley beats JMM anytime, and the pac fight is close but i have PACMAN winning a decision and getting the belt back

Agree. Beating JMM beats anything Donaire's ever done.

And yes, I think the Pac/Bradley fight's gonna be extremely close.

[M Bison]

1 Pacquiao
2 Bradley
3 JMM
4 Thurman
5 Shawn Porter

[Larry the boss]

In his last 5 fights he would've fought Bradley and Marquez a combined four times. Those are your 2nd and 3rd ranked WW's

Top 5

Floyd
Manny
Bradley
JMM
Maidana

but they were unranked when he fought them

[Larry the boss]

he already beat bradley ......smfh.....

well no he didnt,and even then Bradley was not a ranked ww

[BUNGALOWS]

Its not like im saying he the worse WW on the planet. Hes 6 on my list but this is top 5.

STOP. IT.

[Dinamita 03]

I have Thurman on my list based on talent rather than resume, people don't know what he's fully capable of yet. We've all seen what Maidana is capable of. He's very limited and predictable. Also, even though he's been around for longer, I'd argue that Thurman and Porter have better resumes than him. Diego Chaves, Quintana, Alexander etc are better than Broner, who's Maidana's best win.

It's all subjective like you say, but I wouldn't surprised if most people including Maidana in their top 5 are Floyd fanboys, tryna hype him up.

Again it's all personal choice which is fine it just further proves my point that either Maidana, Thurman, Porter can be top 5.

For example going by resume Thurman's best win was against a though veteran in Soto-Karass whom Maidana already beat. His second best win against Chaves is not as good as beating Broner who was slightly more proven and at least the champ on paper. Quintana was also nowhere near his best so you can't rank that win over Maidana's win over Lopez who had his carter defining victory over Ortiz his last fight at WW.

[Fetta]

STOP. IT.

YOu going to get on Keith who just listed his top 5 and Floyds not even on it?

[El Angel]

1. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Timothy Bradley Jr.
4. Juan Manuel Marquez
5. Marcos Maidana

[WilkinsOlajuwon]

A top 5 doesnt mean all 5 are good.

[BUNGALOWS]

YOu going to get on Keith who just listed his top 5 and Floyds not even on it?

When in the bloody hell did I say he's not on my list?

If I said Pac is #2, that obviously means Floyd's #1, unless there's some imaginary fighter out there that I think is better than Floyd and Pac.