Does Marcos Maidana "murder" a prime Ricky Hatton?

[ThePunchingBag]

Maidana doesn't have the speed or footwork to catch Hatton flush and avoid Hatton's shots at the same time.

@140 Hatton wins it 8/10 times.

@147 Hatton wins it 6/10 times.

[GhostBlade]

Picking Maidana at this point vs prime Hatton. Maidana just has the advantage all around and I think Maidana TKO Hatton in the 6th or 7th round.

[CraigM]

People acting like beating broner makes you a superstar = lol
He has no chance vs Hatton

[sugarsmosley]

why does everyone **** on "prime" hatton, he lost to two of the best of his generation PACMAN and floyd. it's not like he lost a decision to demarcus corely and got knocked out by emanuel augustus.

[Tom Cruise]

Maidana can't take body shots, can't clinch, doesnt know how to work in a clinch, and and cant fight backing up.

I don't rate Hatton much but he'd have been too much for Maidana

Pretty much this...

I dont think Maidana would want to work at the distance Hatton would force him to work at.

[Tom Cruise]

Anytime Hatton fought at 147, he looked like pure Shyt.

Maidana all day

Maidana loses to prime Collazo and Prime Floyd easily.

Lets not act like Hatton looked bad against bums when he came up in weight

edit: please dont come back with Senchenko... that doesn't count lol

[bojangles1987]

I'm fairly certain Hatton beats Maidana.

[Boxing Goat]

Prime Hatton, the one that busted up Tszyu would smother and abuse Maidana's body and stop him.

That said, styles make fights and I think Marcos has what it takes to make a good, exciting fight with Floyd, but unless he lands a money punch, he can't beat him by decision.

[TGD]

Maidana would not be getting up from classic Hatton body shot. Good fight while it lasts, but Hatton folds Maidana.

[Derranged]

I don't know who would have won, but I seriously doubt Maidana would have "murdered" Hatton. I think it would be a close, hard fought "war of wills" so to speak.