Has Golovkin earned a spot in the Top 5 p4p?

[ShoulderRoll]

Are you sure he put GGG in his p4p list or on the Gatti List?

It was the p4p list.

The Gatti List is ridiculous as well though and another bunch of bull**** used to hype HBO house fighters. To think that I used to really enjoy Lampley.

Ring Magazine is really no better what with them having Broner ranked in the top 10. I just want to see good, thoughtful analysis come back again instead of this badly concealed shilling for specific networks or promoters.

[Russian Crushin]

It was the p4p list.

The Gatti List is ridiculous as well though and another bunch of bull**** used to hype HBO house fighters. To think that I used to really enjoy Lampley.

Ring Magazine is really no better what with them having Broner ranked in the top 10. I just want to see good, thoughtful analysis come back again instead of this badly concealed shilling for specific networks or promoters.

No way, a guy working for HBO, with his own show on HBO about HBO boxing is hyping up HBO fighters? I for one am shocked.

[RubenSonny]

GGG will be in the top 5 after he takes care of Martinez

As for Lampley............dudes just a nut case.

Why would beating Martinez put him in the top 5? The guy would be 40 by the time they could fight, with bad knees and has looked awful and washed up against mediocre Murray who arguably beat him. Why is that a great win? He's not an elite fighter anymore, far from it, you guys put weight to much stock in a title and name value rather than looking at their quality as a fighter.

[ShoulderRoll]

No way, a guy working for HBO, with his own show on HBO about HBO boxing is hyping up HBO fighters? I for one am shocked.

Their p4p list on HBO was always fairly objective before. Why the sudden change?

I wager that it's because Floyd left and they started to panic a little.

[RubenSonny]

Macklin gets vastly overrated on here, dude got planked by Jamie Moore

[Ray*]

Well the way some idiots were talking about him 12 months ago you would think he was lord himself.

[Daddy T]

big fan of GGG but top 5 hell no

[Ray*]

Why would beating Martinez put him in the top 5? The guy would be 40 by the time they could fight, with bad knees and has looked awful and washed up against mediocre Murray who arguably beat him. Why is that a great win? He's not an elite fighter anymore, far from it, you guys put weight to much stock in a title and name value rather than looking at their quality as a fighter.

Typical of the what we have talking about, Kerry hope beat Proksa before GGG beat him in September 2012, Macklin had one single round under his belt and was at his worse coming from injury after losing to Martinez when he was rushed to fight GGG, The only fighter who GGG beat that was on roll was Curtis Steven and even he was a d- level fighter at best, Rosado was a Light middleweight coming up and lost all his big fights prior and after GGG, And then who else? Ishida? Amanda? I like GGG personally because you can see he brings excitement, power and guarantee fireworks but some of these fanatics are plucked up boxing fans.

[Derranged]

Na. But honestly I never really paid much attention to P4P lists anyway.

[Kagami Taiga]

Na. But honestly I never really paid much attention to P4P lists anyway.

I think they're hilarious