Duran lost biggest fights yet PFP great.

[ironmt]

Marvin's comp at 160 was much more ferocious than Durans at 135. Durans top 30 rank comes from his body of work at 135 comp wise I give it a C, Buchanan dejesus, and a few others can't compare to,

What hagler had to go through with his reign. I rate guys who moved up and dominated over guys who only dominated one weight class. That's my criteria others say you only need to beat one fighter and you automatically get int the top ten. Lmao not mine.

If your criteria Is based on level of competition, moving up In weight and titles as your previous posts Indicate, how Is It possible to have Mayweather at number 3, yet Pacquiao didn't make the list.

[LacedUp]

Brandish, how many ATGs do Floyd have on his resume?

[Brandish]

If your criteria Is based on level of competition, moving up In weight and titles as your previous posts Indicate, how Is It possible to have Mayweather at number 3, yet Pacquiao didn't make the list.

Pacquiao has all of 6 title defenses that's pathetic especially considering this era. PAC like Duran would win a title but never defend it or prove how dominate the y are.

If you look at pacs career all time you could probably place him all time at 122? I'm stretching here because I rank morales and Barrera ahead of PAC at 122! They did more at the weight. PAC fans like Duran fans look for one victory to hoist their guy up on a. Pedestal for PAC its Barrera Duran it's Leonard no matter what they did afterwards those two victories make them top ten ATG ahead of charley burley, Ezzard Charles, jersey joe, Sam Langford yeah right

[Brandish]

Brandish, how many ATGs do Floyd have on his resume?

Oscar de la Hoya top 40-50 ATG
Shane Mosley top 40-50 ATG

[LacedUp]

Pacquiao has all of 6 title defenses that's pathetic especially considering this era. PAC like Duran would win a title but never defend it or prove how dominate the y are.

If you look at pacs career all time you could probably place him all time at 122? I'm stretching here because I rank morales and Barrera ahead of PAC at 122! They did more at the weight. PAC fans like Duran fans look for one victory to hoist their guy up on a. Pedestal for PAC its Barrera Duran it's Leonard no matter what they did afterwards those two victories make them top ten ATG ahead of charley burley, Ezzard Charles, jersey joe, Sam Langford yeah right

Who would you have liked Pacquiao to fight who he didn't fight?

[LacedUp]

Oscar de la Hoya top 40-50 ATG
Shane Mosley top 40-50 ATG

Didn't Mayweather need to beat Oscar twice in order to really beat him? Wasn't it closer than Duran-Leonard?

Shane Mosley is not a top 50 ATG. It's arguable whether he's an ATG or not. I can certainly see why a lot of people would say he's 'just' a HOFer.

[Brandish]

Who would you have liked Pacquiao to fight who he didn't fight?

You can't fight everybody so I don't knock PAC for not fighting Floyd and his career isn't based on one fighter. He lost to torrecampo but he came back to win some big fights it's when you compare him to other skilled fighters who have competed in his weight class you realize how limited he was.

PAC all time is 70-80 very flashy but he never showed he could dominate a division and reign as the best. Hence the joke around here is everyone thinking PAC and Floyd were on the same level it's too funny.

[ironmt]

Pacquiao has all of 6 title defenses that's pathetic especially considering this era. PAC like Duran would win a title but never defend it or prove how dominate the y are.

If you look at pacs career all time you could probably place him all time at 122? I'm stretching here because I rank morales and Barrera ahead of PAC at 122! They did more at the weight. PAC fans like Duran fans look for one victory to hoist their guy up on a. Pedestal for PAC its Barrera Duran it's Leonard no matter what they did afterwards those two victories make them top ten ATG ahead of charley burley, Ezzard Charles, jersey joe, Sam Langford yeah right

One victory to hoist their guy up on a pedestal?

Ok, I thought you were trying to have a legitimate debate, I was wrong.

You are not qualified to form an opinion on Durans greatness.

[Dean_Razorback]

I get the feeling you have just taken a bunch of fighters, mixed in your two favs (roy and floyd) and hatched them all together. Put roy and floyd high, but not high enough to be called out on your fanboyism.

Yet, your list is dumb.

Oscar de la Hoya top 40-50 ATG
Shane Mosley top 40-50 ATG

are you king fantom in boxing asylum????

[MrTambourineMan]

Oscar de la Hoya top 40-50 ATG
Shane Mosley top 40-50 ATG

You're the gift that keeps on giving.