Would Floyd actually outbox Rigondeaux p4p?

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Floyd is a level above Donaire, I'd say hes about equal with Oscar though.

Oscar is way better than donaire,,, both beat up smaller guys coming up,

oscar beat up molina, leija, genaro,
donaire beat up navreaz, montiel, vic

but oscar also beat pernell
donaire got totally undressed by rigo

donaire is now struggling with old vic
oscar was throwing down with prime ike, tito, shane, vargas, hopkin, floyd, manny, and only really got blown out vs hopkins and manny,,

donaire is nowhere near oscar,, dont get caught up with him looking like a million bucks vs montiel, arce,,,, The dude struggles badly vs a top level guy,,, Oscar never got dismantled like donaire did vs rigo,, and pernell, shane, tito, ike, vargas, hopkins, floyd can undress some fools
Oscar was a great fighter and has the toughest resume of anyone in recent times,,
Nobody goes thru oscar's resume undefeated

[Sugar Adam Ali]

over 24 title defenses in his career and you don't think he should be in the hall of fame? Why, because he fights in Argentina?

Yeah pretty much, name his top level wins,,,

It is very easy to grab a title and hold it for ransom for years,,

look at sven ottke, chris john, etc....

title defenses much like knockout streaks can be easily manipulated, especially in this age of 4 major belts, plus super champs and interm champs etc...

Who are his best wins?????

[rr00676]

but oscar also beat pernell

So gift decisions make you a better fighter? Cmon now.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

So gift decisions make you a better fighter? Cmon now.

It wasnt a give,, super close, but not a gift,, could have gone either way,,

unlike donaire who barely won 2 rounds,

plus if your going to say oscar got a gift vs pernel,, then you gotta say he beat tito and shane in the rematch

Do you think honestly donaire is better than oscar????? just think about it