Is there an argument for Hopkins to be top 10-15 ATG?

[Larry the boss]

20 title defenses at Middleweight=most ever at middleweight

Oldest Lineal champion ever

Oldest fighter to ever win a major title

Oldest fighter to ever defend a major title

[PAC-BOY]

Top 10 IMO.

[IronDanHamza]

Absolutely not.

[bojangles1987]

No.

I hate how Larry never mentions names in these threads. He always just lists accomplishments with no context.

[KO'er]

Yes IMO.

His resume is as good as anybody in history. 20 successful defences of a title, up there with any ATG.

[JDezi4]

If he fought in the 60's or 70's he would be

[bojangles1987]

Yes IMO.

His resume is as good as anybody in history. 20 successful defences of a title, up there with any ATG.

No, not even close.

[Thickback]

In terms of skill and accomplishments, yes. But far too often people let their feelings towards his "antics" get in the way of true assessment of what this man has truly done.

[Ray Corso]

He's not a top ten middleweight let along 10 to 15 EVER!! Fanatic===Blindness!

[Larry the boss]

Absolutely not.

why not?

No.

I hate how Larry never mentions names in these threads. He always just lists accomplishments with no context.

wins over

Pavlik
Glenn Johnson
Oscar
Tito
Winky
Cloud
Pascal
Tarver

He's not a top ten middleweight let along 10 to 15 EVER!! Fanatic===Blindness!

Name 10 better middleweights sir