Is there an argument for Hopkins to be top 10-15 ATG?

[Jack Napier]

hell no
every time somebody wins a belt, this crap comes up
Hopkins is adding slowly to a good resume
Murat doesn't add much alone, nor did Cloud or Pascal
Hopkins has decent to good wins piling up over a long period
he doesn't have the resume to be up that high though

[WilkinsOlajuwon]

10-15 nope but higher than Manny or Floyd thats for sure.

[DosRounds]

He's great but I can't say whether he's a top 10-15 ATG

[A$AP FANTOM]

If he fought in the 60's or 70's he would be

This.

Any active fighter gets ridiculously underrated.

[Larry the boss]

This.

Any active fighter gets ridiculously underrated.

sure seems that way

[A-Wolf]

Bernard Hopkins is one of the greatest fighters of all time and he will be regarded that way more and more as the years go on. 10-15 ATG? Sure. I got no problems with that.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

He is an ATG, but i dont think he is top 15 ATG, he is probably around 30-75 range depending on what criteria you use,,,,

I dont think you could have him higher than a duran or hearns,,,,,,,, Roy jones beat him, so in theory jones would be ranked higher if going by H2H......

No disrespect to HOpkins,,,, He is a great fighter, i just dont think he is a top 15 guy,,,

I cant place him up there with the SRL, SRR, ALI class,,,,

[AntonTheMeh]

If he fought in the 60's or 70's he would be

he'd have monzon and hagler to deal with, so yeah, if he had those two on his resume, it would be hard to argue he wasn't.

[- Ram Raid -]

All time? . . . Not for me.

Last 20 years? . . . Without doubt.

[01samuelc]

How does beating up undersized men and loses to the decent fighters he faced in roy jones, joe calzaghe chad dawson and taylor make bhop a top 10 atg.