Of all Floyd's ducks, who would have beaten him?

[RawDawgHasSpokn]

I think tszyu, pacman, Williams, and margarito all would have KO'd Floyd.

I knew this thread was bad but when I got to Kostya Tszyu I realized there was a deeper problem.



Take two and adjust post accordingly

[Jc8804]

Williams and margarito at the times would have gave floyd
The heat

[The Ninth Layer]

Williams got outboxed by carlos quintana. Floyd could do the same.
Magarito has never beat anybody. Why would you pick him over floyd?

I wouldn't pick either of them over Floyd, but I would think both fighters would give him trouble through 12 rounds.

[Tylotto]

The way some of you guys talk up Margarito is insane. He was a slightly above average brawler that's it. If anyone thinks his slow ass could've KO'd Floyd in his prime needs to follow another sport.

[Derranged]

Everybody who fights Floyd, their punch output drops significantly. No way Margarito throws a 120 punches per round against him.

Warrios is just a troll.

[Frank Ducketts]

I think tszyu, pacman, Williams, and margarito all would have KO'd Floyd.

Only a clown would list inferior guys that not only beat Floyd but ko him. Only a clown.

[BendOver]

I think Paul williams and Margarito at 147 in their prime would had been a very tough fight for him, Casamayor at 130 back then could had been a classic, I'm not going to say that they would had mop the floor witgh FMJ or viceversa, just that it could be too close to call

[JaguaresMx]

didn't present triangle theories....

purely style matchups.... and how pacquiao can't adapt to a counterpuncher....

cos marquez can clearly be outboxed.... pacquiao just doesn't have the tools to outbox a counter puncher....


and no one said floyd would ko williams.

what frustrates me is that we'll never really know. For whatever reason, these kind of fights didn't happen. I still think Paul gives Floyd all kinds of problems due to the size issue, more than pac would have.

I would have paid 200$ for prime floyd vs prime pac.

just a frustrated, blue balled boxing fan

[Tylotto]

A 36 year old Floyd will shutout a prime Margarito.

[Meanrighthook29]

Prime Paul Williams is the only guy I could've imagined giving Floyd a tough fight or beating him and that's cause he was 6 feet tall and had a huge reach advantage but as someone pointed out he never really fought "tall" so who knows. Pacquaio, no and margarito was a bum who will only be remembered as a cheat so he's irrelevant. Rigondeaux and Andre ward could keep up with Floyd right now, but obviously ones too small. The other too big.