Margarito v Cotto: A Great Fight Shrouded

Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • soul_survivor
    LOL @ Ali-Holmes
    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
    • Jun 2013
    • 18949
    • 623
    • 473
    • 65,236

    #1

    Margarito v Cotto: A Great Fight Shrouded

    By 2008 Miguel Cotto was PR boxing's biggest star and possibly the leading fighter at 147lb, Antonio Margarito was the Mexican bad man, hard hitting and uncompromising. Cotto was given the star treatment whereas Margarito had to come up the hard way, gathering losses as he went. This was a fight between two very different men and both had to prove something.

    Margarito wanted to show everyone he was more than just a hard man.

    Cotto wanted to show everyone he was worthy of his p4p stature and ranking.

    The fight itself was as good as it gets the early rounds belonged squarely to Cotto, who boxed, moved and out landed Margarito but for everyone 3 punches Margarito took, he would land one...and they hurt.

    As the fight swung toward the 5th and 6th rounds, it was obvious that Cotto's early points lead my not mean much, Margarito was starting to land the more telling punches. It had shades of Taylor v Chavez, where Chavez battered Taylor in the championship rounds. I didn't want to see that, I kept thinking that Cotto would mount a come back but by the 11th it was obvious that the scorecards would most likely be even and that Cotto may not take much more.

    Margarito finished it in the 11th, pounding Cotto on the ropes and the great Puerto Rican took a knee.

    Sadly, the fight is no longer remembered for the great contest it was, now all people talk about is how Cotto quit and how that somehow defines an entire nation. Margarito's detractors point to the hearsay that he may have been using illegal substances in his gloves, although there has never been any evidence of that.

    I just wish more people would talk about this on the merit of the two fighters, the skill, guts and damn will that both men showed, rather than the negatives. In welterweight history this should be up there with Leonard/Hearns.
  • bojangles1987
    bo jungle
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Jul 2009
    • 41118
    • 1,326
    • 357
    • 63,028

    #2
    Such a good fight. I don't know whether Margarito cheated or not, but the fight was a classic. Decrying Cotto for quitting is moronic, he gave everything he had. Fans can't ask for more than what Cotto gave.

    Comment

    • soul_survivor
      LOL @ Ali-Holmes
      Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
      • Jun 2013
      • 18949
      • 623
      • 473
      • 65,236

      #3
      Originally posted by bojangles1987
      Such a good fight. I don't know whether Margarito cheated or not, but the fight was a classic. Decrying Cotto for quitting is moronic, he gave everything he had. Fans can't ask for more than what Cotto gave.
      I know! It's not as if he pulled an Ortiz, Cotto fought till he couldn't give any more, mentally and physically. He gave Margarito the fight of his life, people tend to forget that Margarito was never the same after that fight either.

      Comment

      • JmH Reborn
        Undisputed Champion
        Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
        • Feb 2009
        • 4874
        • 238
        • 127
        • 12,377

        #4
        It was an incredible fight

        I really don't know why it didn't win FOTY. It had everything. Momentum swings, comebacks, blood, guts, skills, techniques, brawling, and to top it off, they were the two best WW at the time. What more can be asked. I recognize that that Vasquez/Marquez III happened too, but more was on the line in this battle

        Comment

        • JmH Reborn
          Undisputed Champion
          Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
          • Feb 2009
          • 4874
          • 238
          • 127
          • 12,377

          #5
          Originally posted by soul_survivor
          I know! It's not as if he pulled an Ortiz, Cotto fought till he couldn't give any more, mentally and physically. He gave Margarito the fight of his life, people tend to forget that Margarito was never the same after that fight either.
          They both beat the prime out of eachother. It was one of those wars.

          People talk about Pac softening Margarito up for Cotto,

          But Cotto softened Margarito up for Shane and Pac. Margs then softened Cotto for Pac.

          Those two shaved off years from their careers from eachother

          Comment

          • soul_survivor
            LOL @ Ali-Holmes
            Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
            • Jun 2013
            • 18949
            • 623
            • 473
            • 65,236

            #6
            Originally posted by JmH Reborn
            They both beat the prime out of eachother. It was one of those wars.

            People talk about Pac softening Margarito up for Cotto,

            But Cotto softened Margarito up for Shane and Pac. Margs then softened Cotto for Pac.

            Those two shaved off years from their careers from eachother
            Yeah, they put everything on the line. It's rare in boxing in the age of alphabet titles where two legitimate champions, both in their primes, are willing to do something like this. Garcia and Matthysse is a very good example but that didn't live up to the hype.

            We need to stop criticising fighters who put everything on the line even when they dont need to.

            Brave men like Khan, Garcia, Cotto, Margarito (understandably?), Donaire get more flack than guys who never seem to take a step up. Yes they have losses to their names, so what? They fought the best.

            Comment

            • JmH Reborn
              Undisputed Champion
              Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
              • Feb 2009
              • 4874
              • 238
              • 127
              • 12,377

              #7
              Originally posted by soul_survivor
              Yeah, they put everything on the line. It's rare in boxing in the age of alphabet titles where two legitimate champions, both in their primes, are willing to do something like this. Garcia and Matthysse is a very good example but that didn't live up to the hype.

              We need to stop criticising fighters who put everything on the line even when they dont need to.

              Brave men like Khan, Garcia, Cotto, Margarito (understandably?), Donaire get more flack than guys who never seem to take a step up. Yes they have losses to their names, so what? They fought the best.
              I've thought Margarito was suspect about his career, but even then, he went out like a man.

              I like my fighters to experience losses, shows what they're made of.

              Kahn's biggest issue is his mouth. He reminds me of a JuanMa Lopez, thinking they're sh-t don't stink and that they're worth more than they are. But I respect Kahn's willingness to fight the good fights

              Comment

              • DARKSEID
                Banned
                Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                • Jan 2010
                • 17578
                • 962
                • 512
                • 43,940

                #8

                Comment

                • Dinamita 03
                  Rolin
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Apr 2013
                  • 3677
                  • 214
                  • 178
                  • 18,652

                  #9
                  Truly a modern day classic, besides marquez vs pacquiao 4 the most memorable fight I've watched . Really had everything you could ask for great boxing, toe to toe action, and a decisive winner no judging controversies.

                  Comment

                  • Bigg Rigg
                    The People's Champion
                    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                    • Jan 2013
                    • 11387
                    • 280
                    • 58
                    • 20,735

                    #10
                    Tremendous fight!!! Classic stuff. I watched the fight so many times after it first happened. After the Shane fight with tony being caught, I tried to watch it and couldn't. It actually hurts me when I start to see Margarito take over and Cotto fighting for dear life. Because I don't think tony did it clean. I just can't believe he didn't cheat vs Cotto but decided to cheat vs Mosley. Cheating is throwing away your honor because you don't think you can do it the right way. Why would Margarito feel like that after beating Cotto??? I would feel like super man, can't nobody beat me.
                    Last edited by Bigg Rigg; 10-09-2013, 12:25 PM.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP