Marquez knocked out Pacquiao. Is he greater than Pacquiao?

[Frank Ducketts]

My vote goes to Marquez. You can beat a man, but knock him unconscious? Pac has the shinier names on his resume, but both have fought good comp. Just let my comment ride.

[solo20]

JMM is greater then Pac ,MAN TO MAN Pac can not hold his balls he show this by putting Pac face first a$$ up on the ring. as far as in accomplishments Pac gets the nod comes down to how you look at it

[HeroBando]

My vote goes to Marquez. You can beat a man, but knock him unconscious? Pac has the shinier names on his resume, but both have fought good comp. Just let my comment ride.

So IYO Tarver > RJJ. Gotcha

[HeroBando]

I think its pretty darn close. This Bradley fight would tip the scale for JMM IMO.

I dont put much into divisional titles because there are too many classes and belts and paper champs to butter up a resume. Names mean a whole lot more that titles

It's not even close in terms of names. Take JMM's best non Pac win, and it might not fit in Pac's top 10

[hugh grant]

If yes. Why?
If no. Why?

JMM is not greater, as Pac has beat JMM more times, and was beating him before being ko'ed. And Pac has the better resume as well.
Style wise JMM is the worse type of fighter Pac can get, yet still beat him. Pac is JMMs dream style to fight, yet pac gave JMM nightmares. Either way, Pac is better.
The fact that JMM knocked Pac out means nothing. As Floyd dont ko anyone so will he get penalized.?

[crold1]

It's not even close in terms of names. Take JMM's best non Pac win, and it might not fit in Pac's top 10

Marco Antonio Barrera

I'd rate Pac over JMM. Said before I think pac's run from 01-09 is as good as any run since the prime of Pea. But No need for hyperbole.

[The Big Dunn]

JMM is not greater, as Pac has beat JMM more times, and was beating him before being ko'ed. And Pac has the better resume as well.
Style wise JMM is the worse type of fighter Pac can get, yet still beat him. Pac is JMMs dream style to fight, yet pac gave JMM nightmares. Either way, Pac is better.
The fact that JMM knocked Pac out means nothing. As Floyd dont ko anyone so will he get penalized.?

why are you bringing up floyd in a discussion about JMM and Manny?

[WilkinsOlajuwon]

It's not even close in terms of names. Take JMM's best non Pac win, and it might not fit in Pac's top 10

Barrera isn't in Pac's top 10? Dude...really? I think you brain farted

[HeroBando]

Marco Antonio Barrera

I'd rate Pac over JMM. Said before I think pac's run from 01-09 is as good as any run since the prime of Pea. But No need for hyperbole.

Circe MAB 2, and a lot of people don't have this as a Pac top 10 win despite MAB just going life and death and knocking down JMM. Pac turned him into a runner and glove toucher, gave Mosley the blueprint. Only time ever you seen MAB and Mosley playing keepaway and trying to be friends in the ring.

[The Big Dunn]

It's not even close in terms of names. Take JMM's best non Pac win, and it might not fit in Pac's top 10

didn't JMM beat Barrera, which is Pac's best win? Man you ****ing pac fans are the absolute worst sometimes. You don't even ****ing know who he beat yet you are claiming he's better than JMM based on resume.