Better resume: Mares or Donaire?

[Bushidō]

Donaire has

- Darchinyan who was top 12 P4p during the time he Ko him.
- Montiel who was top 8 P4p.
- then Bunch of Undefeated & former champs on his resume!

Mares best win was PDL? hahaha
-He lost to Darchinyan! Got a gift!

Montiel wasn't close to the top 10 p4p but he was a very good fighter..the way Donaire beat him DAMN!

[PACnPBFsuck]

If you think Montiel was a top P4P fighter when Doniare beat him you need to put down the pipe and seek serious help from a professional.

Montiel wasn't close to the top 10 p4p but he was a very good fighter..the way Donaire beat him DAMN!

By Dave Lahr: Former IBF flyweight champion Nonito Donaire (25-1, 17 KO’s) is currently at the number #5 spot for The Ring’s pound-for-pound rankings, whereas his February 19th opponent WBC/WBO bantamweight champion Fernando Montiel (44-2-2, 34 KO’s) is at the number #7 spot. I expect those rankings to be changed dramatically after they face each other at the Mandalay Bay Resort & Casino, in Las Vegas, Nevada.
Read more at http://www.boxing news24.com/2011/01/donaire-montiel-fernando-will-knock-nonito-off-the-rings-pound-for-pound-list/#1ckcLrj3CK2hqIcV.99

http://www.boxing news24.com/2011/01/donaire-montiel-fernando-will-knock-nonito-off-the-rings-pound-for-pound-list/

Maybe you guys weren't watching this division back then, because this isn't new news.

[Bushidō]

http://www.boxing news24.com/2011/01/donaire-montiel-fernando-will-knock-nonito-off-the-rings-pound-for-pound-list/

Maybe you guys weren't watching this division back then, because this isn't new news.

that's one websites claim but I never had Montiel in the top 10 at that time.

[PACnPBFsuck]

that's one websites claim but I never had Montiel in the top 10 at that time.

We found your problem

[-PBP-]

that's one websites claim but I never had Montiel in the top 10 at that time.

Manny Pacquiao
Floyd Mayweather Jr.
Sergio Gabriel Martinez
Juan Manuel Marquez
Nonito Donaire
Pongsaklek Wonjongkam
Fernando Montiel
Wladimir Klitschko
Timothy Bradley
Juan Manuel Lopez

http://boxrec.com/media/index.php/Th...r_Pound--2010s

[-PBP-]

Why do people hate Donaire so much? He has ***** like tendencies but you can deny that he was on a rampage and a top 5 pound for pound fighter going into the Rigondeaux fight.

[HeroBando]

Why do people hate Donaire so much? He has ***** like tendencies but you can deny that he was on a rampage and a top 5 pound for pound fighter going into the Rigondeaux fight.

I think cause he's a whiner, and cause people always felt he was beating up on midgets. But hardly anyone is consistent on beating up the midgets, most everyone has some fighter they like that was huge for his division.

[GRboxing]

Mares definitely has the deeper resume. And the loss to Rigo was embarrassing stuff

[BafanaBafana]

Why do people keep bringing up Yohnny Perez as part of Mares' resume? A DRAW is not a win, might as well bring up Rigondeaux for Donaire. Beating Moreno at 122 is not the same as beating him at 118. Mares has never actually fought a 122 pounder and was gift wrapped a vacant belt there so he's technically only a 2 division titleholder. He also went life and death against Darchinyan (above his best weight and prime) and in the Agbeko I fight; he could just as easily lost those fights and hardly anyone would have complained. Mares is looking better now because at 126 he is closer to his natural weight, he was probably terribly weight drained at 118. He looked like a pillow puncher below 126, where he mostly won fights based on constant pressure and workrate.

Donaire (4 division titleholder): Nishioka (TKO9), Mathebula (UD), Narvaez (UD), Montiel (TKO2), Sidorenko (KO4),Tyson Marquez (TKO8), Concepcion (UD), Mthlane (TKO6), Darchinyan (TKO5)

Mares (2 division titleholder): PDL (TKO9), Moreno (UD), Agbeko (MD/UD), Darchinyan (SD)


How is this even close?

[bojangles1987]

Nonito slightly, but clearly.