Can you be considered an ATG when these are your 10 best wins?

[Weebler I]

Do you think I really care what anyone on the internet thinks of me my friend? If this was so obvious for all to see we wouldn't have morons claiming otherwise. The point of this thread is when the nuthuggers really look at things they can say anything they want, but when it comes to crunch time they simply can't argue against this. People call me a hater all the time (and I love it!) But would a true hater admit Vittles would be a top contender in any era if not champion? Would they rank them amongst the top 10 heavyweights h2h? Thing is a true boxing fan doesn't bestow greatness on what might be, but what was actually accomplished and against who. So people can say whatever they want about me, it doesn't effect my life the least little bit. But one thing I am is realistic.

You don't think you're underrating his opponents? I see a lot of people mention old timers in this thread but most of them were cruiserweight size and weight who likely would have struggled against today's 'super-heavy' generation.

How about letting people decide without throwing in your comments ripping each opponent?

This. Jab has basically just picked out each opponent's weakest moment and asked us to judge their level on that.

Lol, why do people get so upset when you throw reality in their face?

It's opinion though, not reality.

[Jedi Vader]

Lol, do you really want to go there? And lets not incorporate Wlad into this, this is about Vits. Since 2000, and excluding the years he missed, these are all the top 10 fighters he didn't fight for one reason or another.

Tyson
Holyfield
Tua
Maskaev
Rahman
Ruiz
McCline
O'Quendo
Jones jr
Toney
Golota
Brewster
Barret
Chagaev
Povetkin
Valuev
Dimitrenko
Chambers
Haye
Boystov
Thompson
Helenius
Pulev
Fury

Pretty long list, huh? So much for fighting everybody. I guess we don't have to end the thread after all.

Tremendous post.

Typically, none of the Klitlickers can challenge it either!!!

[Someone88]

Lol, not a single person who voted Vits is an ATG has made an argument as to why that doesn't have to do with make believe fights and how he would fare. You guys need a reality check.

I'll admit that I'm biased that's why I voted for Vitali.

[Madjab]

It's not. His best wins are Peter and Sanders FFS! Going by that Rahman is an ATG heavyweight.

[SBleeder]

Yeah, but he'd beat both Ali and Louis in their primes.

I've seen it with my very own mind.

[JAB5239]

Of course.

My thread is neutral, poll options are yes/no, simple question.

This thread is biased and has only one purpose, to throw mud at the great Vitali Klitschko.

Lol, who's throwing mud? Everything I've said is 100% correct, which is why no one can debate me on it. Poor kid, you sound so upset. Look at the bright side, we have something in common......the majority don't consider Vittles an ATG in BOTH our polls!

[JAB5239]

Seventy five percent of voters agree Vits is not an ATG.

[Weltschmerz]

Lol, who's throwing mud? Everything I've said is 100% correct, which is why no one can debate me on it. Poor kid, you sound so upset. Look at the bright side, we have something in common......the majority don't consider Vittles an ATG in BOTH our polls!

I don't think you're living very wise! Your obsession with Vitali (who's close to your own age and has achieved much more in life) has consumed you.

[JAB5239]

I don't think you're living very wise! Your obsession with Vitali (who's close to your own age and has achieved much more in life) has consumed you.

Why are you so obsessed with my life? Why don't you just explain how Vits is an all time great with such a weak resume? Answer: You can't.

[JAB5239]

Why are you so obsessed with my life? Why don't you just explain how Vits is an all time great with such a weak resume? Answer: You can't.

Stiiiillllll waiting!