Can you be considered an ATG when these are your 10 best wins?

[HWChampion]

Considering YOU were the one who brought nationality into this with >>>>>you shouldn't act all surprised when someone repays you in your own coin.



Would you prefer I list my favorite fighters who aren't from the US? I suspect it's a bit more extensive.....

Poet

By all means feel free to list them. No skin off my nose and regarding the comments above its banter my friend no aggrevation towards America haha.

[StarshipTrooper]

By all means feel free to list them. No skin off my nose and regarding the comments above its banter my friend no aggrevation towards America haha.

No worries then! I thought you were taking shots the way the usual azzholes around here do. Banter I don't mind :hah9: So I won't bore you with a full list I'll just list a few of my favorite Brits off the top of my head:

Bob Fitzsimmons
Herol Graham
Nigel Benn
Chris Eubank
Lennox Lewis

[New England]

i love how casually sanders' win over baby brother is mentioned.

[HWChampion]

No worries then! I thought you were taking shots the way the usual azzholes around here do. Banter I don't mind :hah9: So I won't bore you with a full list I'll just list a few of my favorite Brits off the top of my head:

Bob Fitzsimmons
Herol Graham
Nigel Benn
Chris Eubank
Lennox Lewis

Nice list Benn and Eubank were brilliantly entertaining my top American Boxers are:

Ali
Tyson
Jones
Hagler
Whitaker

Yh I never make spiteful remarks to anyone, and especially not fellow boxing brothers.

[beez721]

Just curious as to what boxingscene thinks about these fighters and if having them as your best wins is enough to make a fighter an all time great heavyweight?

Peter - Crude slugger who went tooth and nail with a former middleweight

Adamek - Former lightheavyweight who's best win at heavy was Arreola

Arreola - Has never beaten another top 10 heavyweight

Donald - His career best win is over a ten years past his best Tim Witherspoon

Hide - His best win was over 11-1 Michael Bentt

Sanders - Never beat a top ten fighter before or after Wlad. Was stopped by Nate Tubbs

Williams - Come on, this is a guy who lost to Julius Francis

Kirk Johnson - Possessed skills but in his biggest fights always came in fat and out of shape

Gomez - Former cruiserweight who beat a few guys thought to be decent but were either past it or went on to accomplish nothing

Solis - Talented but still a novice by professional standards. Ridiculed for never being in shape

isnt there already a similiar thread on this? youre really making yourself look like a klit hater. its obvious vitali does not have the resume to be considered an atg so stop beating a dead horse

[StarshipTrooper]

Nice list Benn and Eubank were brilliantly entertaining my top American Boxers are:

Ali
Tyson
Jones
Hagler
Whitaker

Yh I never make spiteful remarks to anyone, and especially not fellow boxing brothers.

Cheers! It's rather "de rigueur" around here so you'll get your share of it whether you look for it or not :hah9:

Poet

[HWChampion]

Cheers! It's rather "de rigueur" around here so you'll get your share of it whether you look for it or not :hah9:

Poet

Haha thank you for the reminder I'm sure it won't be hard to find haha.

[JAB5239]

isnt there already a similiar thread on this? youre really making yourself look like a klit hater. its obvious vitali does not have the resume to be considered an atg so stop beating a dead horse

Do you think I really care what anyone on the internet thinks of me my friend? If this was so obvious for all to see we wouldn't have morons claiming otherwise. The point of this thread is when the nuthuggers really look at things they can say anything they want, but when it comes to crunch time they simply can't argue against this. People call me a hater all the time (and I love it!) But would a true hater admit Vittles would be a top contender in any era if not champion? Would they rank them amongst the top 10 heavyweights h2h? Thing is a true boxing fan doesn't bestow greatness on what might be, but what was actually accomplished and against who. So people can say whatever they want about me, it doesn't effect my life the least little bit. But one thing I am is realistic.

[LoneLocust]

Well there are some people, even on this very forum, who think that resume is good enough for greatness.

Faulting someone for the era they happened to be born into...

You are ******.

[MASONSC]

Just curious as to what boxingscene thinks about these fighters and if having them as your best wins is enough to make a fighter an all time great heavyweight?

Peter - Crude slugger who went tooth and nail with a former middleweight

Adamek - Former lightheavyweight who's best win at heavy was Arreola

Arreola - Has never beaten another top 10 heavyweight

Donald - His career best win is over a ten years past his best Tim Witherspoon

Hide - His best win was over 11-1 Michael Bentt

Sanders - Never beat a top ten fighter before or after Wlad. Was stopped by Nate Tubbs

Williams - Come on, this is a guy who lost to Julius Francis

Kirk Johnson - Possessed skills but in his biggest fights always came in fat and out of shape

Gomez - Former cruiserweight who beat a few guys thought to be decent but were either past it or went on to accomplish nothing

Solis - Talented but still a novice by professional standards. Ridiculed for never being in shape

How about letting people decide without throwing in your comments ripping each opponent?