Paul Williams vs Ricky Hatton @ 147lbs Who is the GREATER fighter?

[Dirk Diggler UK]

I think astute boxing fans do count the Winky win. Was Winky in his prime? No.

Is past prime Winky better than anyone Hatton has ever beat? Debatable.

That should not be debatable.

Well you're not exactly astute so you must not count it. Winky hadn't been on the radar for literally years. No one counts it for Peter Quillin either

Kostya Tszyu is better than anyone Williams beat. He was the undisputed junior welterweight champion and in almost everyone's top 3 pound for pound when Hatton beat him.