Paul Williams vs Ricky Hatton @ 147lbs Who is the GREATER fighter?

[SterlingStained]

The Hatton that Floyd faced at 147 vs any version of Paul Williams at 147lbs?

Who will be remembered as the greater fighter?

Discuss....

[UTEP]

The same Hatton that lost to Collazo at 147???

[SterlingStained]

Ricky Hatton will be remembered as a better fighter than Paul Williams....period....you guys kill me with this P Dub talk as if he was great or even close to it.

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=602805&page=6

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Who is the greater fighter or who would win in a fight?

In a fight, the size differential would be insane. Hatton was not a Welterweight. Williams would probably be far too big.

Hatton is the greater fighter overall. Had a better career.

[malcolm]

The Hatton that Floyd faced at 147 vs any version of Paul Williams at 147lbs?

Who will be remembered as the greater fighter?

Discuss....

Williams. The whole 147 division ducked him at some point.

Mosley admitted he didn't want none with P Will. Cotto fought Jennings for Williams vacated title instead of fighting Williams when he had the belt.

[Weebler I]

Hatton wasn't a 147lb fighter, he fought there three times and lost twice.

Seems to me you've included the "147" part so as to get the result you want because it bears no relation to the point J made in the other thread.

[AntonTheMeh]

paul beat margs. that's better then anything hatton did at welter.

[Godsfly]

Who is the greater fighter or who would win in a fight?

In a fight, the size differential would be insane. Hatton was not a Welterweight. Williams would probably be far too big.

Hatton is the greater fighter overall. Had a better career.

Williams has a win over prime margarito @ 147..............

[MrTambourineMan]

Did Floyd duck Williams at 147? Yes.

Was Williams greater than Hatton at 147? Yes, especially considering that Hatton's 2 biggest fights at that weight were fights in which one of them he barely sc****d past Luis Collazo and the other in which he was TKO'd by Joe Cortez.

Who had the greater overall career? Hatton.

[Ray*]

Lmaooooo watch Hatton fanatics try to vote for him now....