Floyd Mayweather vs Saul Alvarez Master Thread - Post ALL Related Topics HERE

[dc3383]

So is Showtime not showing a replay of Mayweather/Canelo this weekend? I didn't see it when I did a search.

It will be this Saturday

[RlCKY]

Don't expect CJ Ross to be looked into for her scorecard

http://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/boxing/2013/09/15/nevada-boxing-commission-supports-judge-who-scored-floyd-mayweather-draw/2816871/

Keith Kizer, NSAC boss had the following to say...

"Just because a judge's scorecard ends up even, doesn't mean the judge necessarily thought the fight as a whole was even. It could be that a judge has six rounds for each fighter, but the six rounds she gave fighter A, she gave them to him easily and the six rounds she gave fighter B, they were really close rounds. That's pretty much how it was last night.

lol

That just FURTHERS the case for her incompetence if she thought there were that many close rounds.

And you score ALL of the close rounds to one guy?! If it is really that close of a round, on 6 separate occasions, you don't think at least ONCE you come up with the other guy edging it?

[New England]

You're a good son.

thanks, big dog. we had a great time.

[Carpe Diem]

http://www.usatoday.com/story/sports...-draw/2816871/

Keith Kizer, NSAC boss had the following to say...



lol

That just FURTHERS the case for her incompetence if she thought there were that many close rounds.

And you score ALL of the close rounds to one guy?! If it is really that close of a round, on 6 separate occasions, you don't think at least ONCE you come up with the other guy edging it?

I'm gonna go out on a limb here and say that Floyd would have been robbed if Canelo had won just four clear rounds. The only round that Canelo won was the last round because Floyd coasted through that round as he did against Guerrero. Floyd edged him in every rounds besides the last round and all three of the judges scorecards had the fight closer than it was.

[MrRolltide91]

I'm gonna go out on a limb here and say that Floyd would have been robbed if Canelo had won just four clear rounds. The only round that Canelo won was the last round because Floyd coasted through that round as he did against Guerrero. Floyd edged him in every rounds besides the last round and all three of the judges scorecards had the fight closer than it was.

yep they wanted to make a trilogy out of this

[RlCKY]

I posted this in another thread...pretty interesting considering the outcry as Ms Ross's scorecard. But all this could mean is that nobody gave in a good card...




Ross had at least 1 judge agree with her in 10 of 12 rounds. Only the 1st and 8th rounds she was alone on her score.

Moretti had at least 1 judge agree with him in all 12 rounds.

Metcalfe had at least 1 judge agree with him in 7 of 12 rounds.

Strange judging anomaly here. If you take the "average score" per judge per round, the fight is scored 116-112 Floyd.


Would this kind of system of combining judges scores prevent similar issues from coming up in the future?

Could this come back and give the decision to the wrong boxer if ONE score is averaged out from the 3 judges and turned in??

[BoxingScientist]

me and my old man. his birthday was last weekend. i took him to the fight for his birthday. dude is 66 years old.

Good pic with your pops...I took a photo next to that ring in the MGM Grand this past weekend also. I wonder how much of the Boxing Scene community I was around Saturday.

[Warrios]

floyd is one of the best. but i truly believe in about a years time bam bam will be ready to solve the puzzle. he has all the intangibles and his ring iq is better than ortiz's who gave him hell in 4 rounds...before giving him a way out.

[Carpe Diem]

[Carpe Diem]

floyd is one of the best. but i truly believe in about a years time bam bam will be ready to solve the puzzle he has all the intangibles and his ring iq is better than ortiz's who gave him hell in 4 rounds...before giving him a way out.