which is the more impressive feat:by Pacquiao or Mayweather jr?

[DLT]

MAB had a damn metal plate in his head if i can remember. Someone correct me if i am wrong. It was almost like a Joe Mesi situation leading up that Barrera vs Pac fight.

he did but I didnt wanna nit pick. You could see the writing on the wall for MAB but at the same time he was still a beast at that point so Ill give him the credit for it

[Cinci Champ]

the fact that floyd was a womanbeater caught on roids covered by oscar and the networks while floyd uses illegal xylocaine and embarrasses his dad on tv while acting like a rascist is more impressive, lol, dont forget, floyd is also a great rapper, his song is ****in amazing garbage, he became a dancer and he also became a fake azz wrestler, thats more impressive than anthing in boxing history

didnt pac just beat up an old guy for calling him out for buying votes? funny u bring up music because mannys music is beyond garbage funny how you guys think pac is such a saint you have been badly fooled on that one.

[WARQUEZ]

DLT, you forgot two important factors. Floyd didn't beat Hatton at his best weight, and Corrales didn't even want to fight Floyd at 130, he wanted 135 because he was having trouble making weight.

To keep it fair Pacquiao did beat Morales when he was struggling to make 130 aswell.

[Cinci Champ]

http://sports.yahoo.com/news/manny-pacquiao-accused-vote-buying-assault-campaign-scuffle-040500999.html

funny how that works if it was floyd it would be every where and everyone would be talking about it

[WARQUEZ]

http://sports.yahoo.com/news/manny-p...040500999.html

funny how that works if it was floyd it would be every where and everyone would be talking about it

Red K for you being dumb enough to vote Floyd into office.

[Bolo Punch]

Pacquiao's initial destruction of Barrera is as impressive as Floyd's win over Corrales. Thus, what we're really debating here is if Pacquiao's 5 other wins over Mexican legends is as good as Floyd's win over someone who never looked good at 147lbs. In case you didn't already know, the answer to that is a resounding yes - and if you even try to argue against that then you're just being plain ******.

[Cinci Champ]

i think manny beating the 3 is more impressive then the 2 floyd victories thats for sure

[Grimgash]

Floyd is regarded as the best of his generation by 99% of all fighters and trainers in the sport.... this thread is just nitpicking.

[DLT]

DLT, you forgot two important factors. Floyd didn't beat Hatton at his best weight, and Corrales didn't even want to fight Floyd at 130, he wanted 135 because he was having trouble making weight.

To keep it fair Pacquiao did beat Morales when he was struggling to make 130 aswell.

The Hatton weight thing is offset by Floyd starting 2 weight classes lower than Hatton and Hatton being a naturally bigger guy who is bigger than Floyd on fight night.

I never buy the Chico thing. People always say he was struggling to make weight but 3 and a half years later Chico was still fighting at SFW and was the champ there. To me they just try to discredit Floyd's win. You cant say its a weight problem when nearly 4 years later he's still fighting at that same weight.

Also, check out the fight night weight for Floyd vs Hatton & Chico. Then check out the fight night weights for Pac vs EM 2 & 3. Pac is coming into the ring at 145 pounds for a 130 pound fight. I remember seeing Pac at 145 for a SFW fight while Floyd was 146 in the ring vs Zab at WW

[craigus1990]

i actually thought pac man lost all the marquez fights, that said, i know floyd lost to castillo and got embarassed by a fat version of de la hoya, lol, floyd even dukked the rematch with a fat de la hoya, dlt is dilusional

Yeah Hoya looked so fat and out of shape against Floyd. Moron.