which is the more impressive feat:by Pacquiao or Mayweather jr?

[flat1985]

you sure about the hamed fight? wasn't it 2 1/2 years before manny v MAB?

You really dont like pac do you lol. Barrera was in great form going in to the Pac fight after beating Hamed, Morales and Tapia

[Zano-24]

Most people don't think Marquez won all 4, I'm willing to bet hardly anyone does, have you seen the unofficial scorecards by observers?

His wins can and are counted over Marquez, why can't you deal with that? You aren't fooling anyone by saying *most people believe this* because you got no proof whatsoever!

Would you like a link to all of there fights and how external sources scored them?

I don't remember tying "I". I said "most" people felt Marquez won all 4 fights and that is the flat out truth. There are more people who say Marquez won all 4 then people who said he didn't is what I am saying. I personally believe he won the 1/3 and obviously the 4th because of the KO. The 2nd fight I gave to Manny even though I can see if others would argue against it.

[DeadLikeMe]

Barrera was on a tear when Pac beat him...it is up there with the best wins of the 2000s.

[bravestone]

Barrera was on a tear when Pac beat him...it is up there with the best wins of the 2000s.

It may be the best win of that decade. Or Hopkins/Trinidad

[ADP02]

Hatton weighed more than Mayweather on fight night, the weight was no advantage. He was struggling to make 140 which is why he tried his hand at 147 previously vs Collazo. The Lazcano (shoelace fight) was after Mayweather at 140. Look at the weigh in pics for the Pacquiao fight Hatton looked half dead. Hatton was a very good fighter that outgrew his division but was too small to compete with the big guys at 147.

That is why after his fights at 147 he went back down to 140! BOTH TIMES!!!

How hard is it to comprehend that Hatton was KING at 140 NOT 147? It's not a matter of making weight easier. It's what Hatton can do at 140 that he can't do as easily against the bigger boys at 147.

[ADP02]

The JMM "wins" are debatable to even be wins.

I'm sure that is what you say every time people bring up that Castillo beat Floyd. I'm sure you say that Floyd is really 43-1

[sammiza567]

1st mab fight is only good one. morales was shot after the first fight which he won.

[bojangles1987]

I can't believe there's any debate about this.

Pac crushing Barrera is greater than Corrales and Hatton by itself. Add in Marquez and it's a joke to even compare.

[check hook]

but i do give Floyd 100% credit for that Corrales fight. that will always be his most impressive fight

The thing that is impressive about Floyd is that with the exception of the first Castillo fight he has completely dominated top tier opponents. Since Castillo no. 1 none of his opponents have realistically taken more than 4 rds in any fight he has had. Most of the time they are limited to winning 1-3 rounds.

[check hook]

The Barrera win gives Pac alot of juice in these discussions.