Rate Mayweather and Rigondeaux boxing skills 1-10

[RichCCFC]

Rate on the following criteria and add up for your overall total, this is p4p

Mayweather
Hand speed = 10
Power = 7
Offense = 9
Defense = 10
Footwork = 9
Reflexes = 10
Boxing IQ = 10
Counter punching = 10
Durability = 8
Overall = 83


Rigondeaux
Hand speed = 10
Power = 9
Offense = 9
Defense = 10
Footwork = 10
Reflexes = 10
Boxing IQ = 10
Counter punching = 10
Durability = 7
Overall = 85

[dan_cov]

Rigondeaux
Hand speed = 10
Power = 10
Defense = 10
Footwork = 10
Reflexes = 10
Boxing IQ = 10
Counter punching = 10
Durability = 10

Overall = God status.

[NearHypnos]

In comparison to his division or those near? Rigo showed he's a 10 even in durability vs Donaire. Took a few bombs from the biggest puncher within those weight classes and didnt flinch aside from the on KD he got up from and kept his dominance.


I've also got Floyd at 10 durability. How could you not? We havent even seen this a sshole go down. :|...

[puga]

floyd :
defense = 9
offense= 7
speed= 10
power = 7
balls= 3 (just to throwin it out there)

rigo:
defense= 10
offfense=8 ( not much variety of punches but damaging puncher)
speed= 10
power=9

[-Kev-]

Mayweather

Hand speed = 10
Power = 7
Defense = 10
Footwork = 10
Reflexes = 10
Boxing IQ = 10
Counter punching = 10
Durability = 10

77

Rigondeaux

Hand speed = 10
Power = 7
Defense = 8 [Knocked down twice [Cordova, Donaire + hurt against Marroquin]
Footwork = 10
Reflexes = 10
Boxing IQ = 10
Counter punching = 10
Durability = 10

75

[RichCCFC]

Adding Offense, dumb that I left it out

[LeG00N]

Mayweather

Hand speed = 8
Power = 6
Offense = 6
Defense = 9
Footwork = 8
Reflexes = 9
Boxing IQ = 8
Counter punching = 7.5
Durability = 7
Overall = 68.5


Rigondeaux

Hand speed = 8.5
Power = 9
Offense = 8
Defense = 9
Footwork = 10
Reflexes = 9
Boxing IQ = 9
Counter punching = 9
Durability = 8
Overall = 79
_______________

[RiC-DiC]

Realistic ratings:

Mayweather
Hand speed = 10
Power = 8
Offense = 10
Defense = 10
Footwork = 10
Reflexes = 10
Boxing IQ = 10
Counter punching = 10
Durability = 10
Overall = 88

Rigondeaux
Hand speed = 10
Power = 4
Offense = 1
Defense = 7
Footwork = 10
Reflexes = 10
Boxing IQ = 10
Counter punching = 10
Durability = 3
Overall = 65

[MurkaMan]

Rate on the following criteria and add up for your overall total, this is p4p

Mayweather
Hand speed = 10
Power = 7
Offense = 9
Defense = 10
Footwork = 9
Reflexes = 10
Boxing IQ = 10
Counter punching = 10
Durability = 8
Overall = 83


Rigondeaux
Hand speed = 10
Power = 9
Offense = 9
Defense = 10
Footwork = 10
Reflexes = 10
Boxing IQ = 10
Counter punching = 10
Durability = 7
Overall = 85

Its hard to rate on a system like the one you presented. I will say this; Rigo only has so many counters. Check right hook, straight left counters, and left uppercuts. If you take those away, there's really not more variety left. Mayweather is all over the place with his counters. Rigo has to run allot. Floyd can stand and fight on the inside if he wants. Sometimes if you throw a punch at Rigo that is not close enough to land, he will still move. Floyd is an expert at range and inches. If you throw a punch at him that is a milli-inch away, he will not even blink his eye. He already knows its not close enough to land. He will look dead at the punch, as it stops inches away from his whiskers. Very sure of every single detale of your reach and range. Rigo is one of those guys that was taught the defensive moves to where he can move in all types of ways to avoid a punch. Floyd was taught all of these things as well, but he doesnt always use them. He sometimes already knows that you're an inch too far for your punch to actually land. That alone places Floyd above Pep, Niccoli, Pernell, and Rigo. Its more than defense with Floyd, its instinctively understanding your opponent's reach capabilities. Which is amazing.

[*ANGRY CUBAN*]

May
hand speed: 10
counter punching:9
defense: 10
power: 7
offence: 8
footwork: 8
ring IQ: 10
durability: 10
reflexes:10
total: 82

Rigo
hand speed: 10
counter punching: 10
defence:10
power: 9
offence:8
footwork: 10
ring IQ:10
durability: 9
reflexes: 10
total: 86