Floyds Pulled Ahead of Manny ATG-Wise

[Capncrunch]

I will say what I always say when this comes up they are really close, whatever one you have ahead is fine but if you have them more than 5 spaces apart I can't agree.

I think Floyd has a greater chance of doing more so chances probably favor him being ahead at the end of the game, but the game is still on going so who knows how it really ends.

there is a saying you can't fade late when the other is consistently great

[Tim2daresq]

Pac's resume is better, and he's not scared like Roidweather.

[Capncrunch]

Even when Pac was winning, Floyd was ahead of him.......too many catchweights. Now that Pac's been knocked out its no contest.

yeah the catchweights certainly dampen the wins

[The Gambler1981]

there is a saying you can't fade late when the other is consistently great

Like I said we will see how the game ends.

[miron_lang]

Well the only notable fighters who made Floyd as for now were his fights against Oscar, Hatton, Cotto, Mosley and Marquez.

Pac vs Marquez.was 2-1-1 in favor of Pacquaio despite of the ko loss while Pac beat the hell out of Oscar, Hatton, Mosley and Cotto in one sided fashion gave them the worst beating of their lives.

Now you compare this guy supposed to be greater than Pac (Floyd) the manner how he won against these 4 common opponents (Oscar, Hatton, Mosley, Cotto) vs Pac against them.

Now you add Pac wins and championship belts at 112, 122, 126, 130, 135, 140. 147, 154 and his 4 lineal titles. I hope you get the idea now.

To be fair.

Floyd has wins over Jesus Chavez, Genaro, Corrales, Castillo 2X, Gatti, Zab and Baldomir.


ALL Solid wins but still not enough IMO to overtake Pac.

[Capncrunch]

To be fair.

Floyd has wins over Jesus Chavez, Genaro, Corrales, Castillo 2X, Gatti, Zab and Baldomir.


ALL Solid wins but still not enough IMO to overtake Pac.

Manfredy over gatti imo, Sosa was a good win, he got robbed by spadafora

[revs1227]

no
no and
No

[ΣL CHAPO]

Simple to answer this.

Who has more HOF'ers on there resume and who beat them better?

2+2=4

Pacquaio>Mayweather

[ADP02]

No, R"oach himself said he wouldn't let pac fight Shane "because he was no Oscar AKA he wasn't washed up yet, then waited on cotto because cotto looked like crap against Clottey and signed immediately seeing how vulnerable cotto looked, at a catchweight no less!

shane avoided floyd. floyd wanted shane at lw but shane jumped to welterweight (not that i blame shane. more money for oscar)

AGAIN, Roach new what's up when he spoke to Mosley but so did the rest of us that that fight was not going to happen until after the Cotto fight.

AGAIN, Floyd said NO to fighting Mosley from later 2006 to 2009. Mosley fought Winky(2X), Forrest(2X), younger Oscar(2X), Floyd, Manny, Cotto, Margarito, ..... harder to call him a duck if a fight doesn't materialize.

[Capncrunch]

AGAIN, Roach new what's up when he spoke to Mosley but so did the rest of us that that fight was not going to happen until after the Cotto fight.

AGAIN, Floyd said NO to fighting Mosley from later 2006 to 2009. Mosley fought Winky(2X), Forrest(2X), younger Oscar(2X), Floyd, Manny, Cotto, Margarito, ..... harder to call him a duck if a fight doesn't materialize.

mosley didn't fight cotto/margarito/pac/floyd until he turned floyd down after the vargas fights. he was trying to get his career back on track so it was smart to avoid floyd at the time since he was high risk low reward back then