All Time Great Or Great For His Era?

[KingTito]

I would definitely consider RJJ an ATG among others.

[KickAzz]

I wouldn't consider RJJ an all-time great. just great for his era. he should've rematch James Toney at a higher weight. and he should've rematched Hopkins when that fight was hot. he should've fought Lewis for 25 million and called up Tarver to fight at HW instead of going back down to lt HW.

if RJJ was able to come back from getting KTFO by Tarver and continue to win, then he'd be considered an ATG