Does Floyd Mayweather Jr have a top 5 resume (of the last 25 years)

[Jcsuper]

Ok so can you give me a list of the haters who you think will fornicate with themselves over the poll results

I think we all know who they are lol, Pacboy being the leader of the pack

[Skittlez]

That happens a lot.

"Fighter A beat him and that's better than anything fighter B did so therefore Fighter A>>>Fighter B"

Pretty ****** logic.

Ruben Carters win over Emile Griffith is one of THE greatest wins in the history of the sport.

Better than absolutely any single win that Mayweather, Pacquaio, Whitaker, Roy Jones, Holyfield holds and the list goes on and on and on and on.

Would anyone say Ruben Carter is greater than any of those fighters? No, of course not. ****** way to look at it.

Hey man. who's that in your sig? Is that Issac Smith?

He a g

[Skittlez]

There's some straight up ignorance going on in this poll.

As far as a complete list of wins and where those guys were at the times, he is Top 5.

Only Whitaker, Holyfield, and Pacquiao slightly are clearly above Floyd the last 25 years. Hopkins and Lewis are debatable, but let's list those wins.

Hopkins beat Mercado, Jackson, Holmes, Trinidad, Daniels, Joppy, Allen, De La Hoya, Eastman, Tarver, Wright, Pavlik, and Pascal.

Lewis beat Ruddock, Tucker, Bruno, Jackson, McCall, Akinwande, Golota, Briggs, Holyfield, Grant, Botha, Rahman, and Vitali. I don't give him credit for Tyson, Mike hadn't done anything of note in like 4 years by 2002.

Foyd has beat Genaro, Manfredy, Corrales, C. Hernandez, Chavez, Castillo, Gatti, Judah, Baldomir, De La Hoya, Hatton, Marquez, Mosley, Ortiz, and Cotto.

I may actually give him an edge over Lewis, and it's debatable with Hopkins.

And as far as the others possibly up there....Tyson, Toney, Jones, De La Hoya, Marquez, Barrera, Morales, Floyd has a better list of wins than those guys.

Hey 4corners. Sup man. I like your posts

Can I ask you a question?

Can you list Floyd's top 5 wins in your opinion?

Thanks

[Skittlez]

I think we all know who they are lol, Pacboy being the leader of the pack

who's your favorite fighter jscupser?

[LeG00N]

In what alternate universe is this a good resume over the last 10 years, the best wins are battle worn Cotto or shot ODLH who else 40 year old Mosley? Zab Judah, JMM jumping up two weight classes......GTFO.

Victoriano Sosa

Phillip Ndou

DeMarcus Corley

Arturo Gatti

Sharmba Mitchell

Zab Judah

Carlos Manuel Baldomir

Oscar De La Hoya

Ricky Hatton

Juan Manuel Marquez

Shane Mosley

Victor Ortiz

Miguel Cotto

oh wow, every single one of those is either an okay win or str8 up mediocre

[Skittlez]

oh wow, every single one of those is either an okay win or str8 up mediocre

What does Floyd have to do to get your respect?

[jcarstenm]

Yes. If not top three.

[straightleft]

Let's make this straight, pacquiao isn't in top 5 either. His resume consists of two early KO loses in his career, a lose to Morales, and these current two loses, on by a huge KO. He never necessarily had a great beginning career but till the later part was he suddenly recognized. Yes, his moving up in weight was good but I'm with Atlas when he says it is nowhere as impressive as middle moving to heavyweight or like Robinson moving from welterweight to heavyweight (though never winning a heavyweight title).

Trying to drag Pac resume to Floyd's level is not gonna work dude. You said Pac never had a great beginning in his career showed how clueless you are. Did you know Pac was already a WBC champ and a lineal champ at the age of 19? Did you know by the age of 24 he was already a 3 weight divisions champ and 2 lineal champ beating the best fighters in those divisions (Sasakul 112, Ledwaba 122, Barrera 126). How many 24 year old boxers have belts in 3 weight divisions and 2 lineal titles in boxing history? I forgot Pac also started PRO boxing at 16, maybe as young as 15. Oh yeah Pac never had a great beginning my ass.

No surprise though. You rated Floyd highly as your current top 1 fighter base on what? Because of his 4 fights in the last 6 years against...

weight cheated lightweight Marquez
grandpa Mosley
sucker punched Ortiz
past prime Cotto

right? LMAO

[jtommy]

This is funny stuff man! Floyd fought like once a year for the past 6 years.

Yup... As he is getting older, doesnt look like his quality of opponents is gonna improve either.

[Rossman]

Why is it every time someone honestly looks at Floyd's resume, people say they are hating. Blame Floyd for the vote being 79% against, not all boxing fans.