Is Mayweather a top 10 atg if he beats Martinez??

[J CO]

Why are you even asking this when you have Mosley tied as the top 5 best fighter of all time in your sig?? Maybe I'm missing something?

Simple question,if Mayweather beat Sergio Martinez..Would you consider him(Mayweather)an ATG???

[straightleft]

Simple question,if Mayweather beat Sergio Martinez..Would you consider him(Mayweather)an ATG???

Another coulda, shoulda, woulda pointless thread to bost Floyd legacy through beating fighters in fantasy fights and get credit from it . Typical Floyd fans.

[check hook]

Simple question,if Mayweather beat Sergio Martinez..Would you consider him(Mayweather)an ATG???

Mayweather is already an ATG, but a top 10 ATG?? Even if he beat him at 160 he wouldn't be a top 10 atg.

To be a top 20 or 30 Floyd would have to:

- Had to have somehow fought Kostya Tszyu at 140 before Hatton got that fight and won. This is important as KT was widely recognised as one of the est to do it at 140.
- MP not ***** out in 2009 over drug tests and win that fight.
- Beat SM at 54 or 60.
- Beat some more opponents....guerrero, Alvarez, etc. and get to about 50-0-0

This would place him top 30 or 20. Top 10 is a tough nut to crack when you have guys like Duran and SSR.

[dc3383]

Most have Floyd ranked from 25-40; so bating Sergio wouldn't place him there

[Check_hooks]

He'd still be behind Calzaghe in my ATG book