Who will be remembered as the greater fighter..

[damuttz112]

Yep,

Olympic Silver Medallist
GOAT Crusierweight
Top ATG Heavyweight
4-Time Heavyweight Champion
Fought over 3 decades of champions. (80's, 90's, 00's)
Stacked Resume
Bloody Underrated.

His CV is incredible, just some names:

Carlos De Leon
Muhammad Qawi x2
James Tillis
Buster Douglas
George Foreman
Larry Holmes
Ray Mercer
Rid**** Bowe x3
Mike Tyson x2
Lennox Lewis x2
John Ruiz x3 lol
Michael Moorer x2

[IronDanHamza]

He was the lineal champion in 4 divisions, first man to do so. The catchweight fiasco started when he peaked at Welterweight and I don't really agree with it but he's proven himself there outside of catchweights.

In an ATG sense, Pac will be well above the likes of Holyfield. If you want to compare them skill wise, then I'd have Holyfield above Pac. Apart from Mayweather, who hasn't Pac fought?

It's already set in stone who will be viewed higher in a historical sense.

Perhaps to the newer fans.

To the historians and so forth, nothing is set in stone in that regard at all.

And, plenty will have Holyfield above him.

[MJ223]

I know most of the fighters in the poll careers are not over..But you can't just take prime fighters,I would have to look at overall career...No??

Holyfield has a great body of work period..... His resume is stacked

[damuttz112]

Epic stuff:

[D-MiZe]

Perhaps to the newer fans.

To the historians and so forth, nothing is set in stone in that regard at all.

And, plenty will have Holyfield above him.

Honestly, 20 years from now you will not see Holyfield higher than Pac in any ATG P4P list. I don't care for Pac, someone called him an athletic Gatti and they're not far off but he's achieved feats no one else in the sport has.

[Capaedia]

Honestly, 20 years from now you will not see Holyfield higher than Pac in any ATG P4P list. I don't care for Pac, someone called him an athletic Gatti and they're not far off but he's achieved feats no one else in the sport has.

That's brilliant

[IronDanHamza]

Honestly, 20 years from now you will not see Holyfield higher than Pac in any ATG P4P list. I don't care for Pac, someone called him an athletic Gatti and they're not far off but he's achieved feats no one else in the sport has.

And? So has Hopkins. Is he above Holyfield too?

Before Pacquaio, Oscar De La Hoya had achieved feats no one else in the sport had, was he above Holyfield then? No.

And, Pacquaio isn't now, IMO.

In 20 years time, he may be considered higher due to his popularity.

But, to legit historians, it's not set in stone, at all.

[The Big Dunn]

Although I'm not a huge fan of his I think Roy will be seen as the greatest on this list

[Rome-By-Ko]

Holyfield has a great body of work period..... His resume is stacked

You will get no argument from me there bro,he has one of the best resumes in all of boxing imo..But I'd still go with MAyweather tho,to be undefeated fighting at his level for this many yrs...Not to mention Mayweather has carried boxing as well..I would have to go with Mayweather..

[P4P_No1]

For me it's Holyfield B-Hop RJJ but Holyfield & RJJ are ruining their legacies by continuing to fight and getting beat up by guys who weren't fit to lace their gloves.

But if we're talking generally, when their career's are done people will look at Floyd & Pac as being the top 2.

Most boxing heads will probably lean towards the 3 I mentioned above (taking nothing away from Pac & Floyd).