Who will be remembered as the greater fighter..

[The Gambler1981]

Who will be remembered as the greatest between the fighters listed??? I said it should be Holyfield as well as voted for him

By your logic or mainstream fans logic we should go by Q ratings and ppv sales..... Correct.?.?.?

In what world does that make sense when not every fighter in history can fit that criteria??? Every fighter in history does have a CV though

Should doesn't mean he will be~

In the real world~

Every fighter has a career that has great detail and that detail is very important, if you don't know the details you don't know much and what you will say will reflect that.

[Porter's Dad]

Look at the first 3 choices. The big dogs in the sport as of right now. You think their stars won't shine less brightly in 10 years time?

Ask the same question 10 years from now and I guarantee it won't be those 3 at the top. Won't be surprised if one, maybe two of them don't have a Roy-like horrible tail end of their careers.

[Skittlez]

Evander Holyfield is the greatest.
Followed by Bernard Hopkins.

Hopkins survived 12 rounds against the best and the 2nd best super middle weights of all times in Calzaghe and Jones.

Mayweather is good, but he aint no HOlyfield.

Evander Holyfield had multiple primes he was so good.

[Skittlez]

Also only complete and utter moronic ******* will argue that

Pacquaio-Holyfield-Floyd-RJJ-Hopkins are not ATG'S.

Hate Pac or hate Floyd or hate RJJ all you like ... they are all 100% ATG'S.


Reading stuff like Pac or Floyd isn't ATG'S is laughable.. ***in morons go grind your own ****** ***s in a cement mixer.

[pturtle]

Look at the first 3 choices. The big dogs in the sport as of right now. You think their stars won't shine less brightly in 10 years time?

Ask the same question 10 years from now and I guarantee it won't be those 3 at the top. Won't be surprised if one, maybe two of them don't have a Roy-like horrible tail end of their careers.

So put Hopkins at number 2 because he survived against Roy and Calzaghe? Even though Roy beat him you have him behind. ****** reason.

[MarkPosadas26]

Definitely Manny Pacquiao will be remembered as the best pound for pound fighter in the world, he never ducked anyone, 8 time world champion in 8 different weight classes, beaten the best out there.

Speed, Power and Footwork.

Juan Manuel Marquez (twice)
Marco Antonio Barrera (twice)
Erik Morales (twice)
David Diaz (rd 9 K.O)
Oscar De la Hoya (rd 8 ODLH quits)
Ricky Hatton (rd 2 K.O)
Joshua Clottey (UD punching bag)
Shane Mosley (UD)
Miguel Cotto (rd 12 stoppage)
Antonio Margarito (UD almost KTFO)
Timothy Bradley (MP definitely beat this *****)
Brandon Rios (UD - MP can K.O this kid but MP choose to outboxed him)

[Hougigo]

I think people will remember Floyd as the better... but people will probably will side with Pacquiao as the greater

[SUCIO416]

the casual fans, which is the biggest % of fans, will choose pacquaio for all the KOs and jumps in weight


but those that know the sport will recognize the atg skill in floyd mayweather boxing