Is a win for kell brook better than any of khans wins?

[.:: JSFD26 ::.]

Unofficially, Kotelnik beat Alexander.

Matthysse too.

And to answer OP, no. Just no. Brook got a lot of ground to cover still.



Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[Rome-By-Ko]

Alexander quit against Bradley and some people thought he lost to Kotelnik (who Khan beat pretty easily).. Alexander isn't a particularly great opponent, but he looks better at 147. If Kell beats him it's a good win for sure, about the same as Khan beating Malignaggi but Khan's resume would still be superior to Brook's at this stage.

Nah dude I totally disagree here..Your comparing Alexander to Paulie M..Dude Alexander is a unified and two div Champ at this point in his career..No matter how ya may feel about it he is more accomplished then Khan with just as good a resume as Khan(if not better)..If Brook should beat Alexander(which tbh I don't see happening)it will be impressive and would put him right in the mix with Khan..Not for overall resume but for quality of a win..

[Bushbaby]

If Kotelnik was given a fair shake in his fight with Alexander, he'd be Khan's biggest win. It's not about who only just won or who dominated, it's who won and who lost. No triangle theory, it's all about levels and Alexander would've been ranked below Kotelnik at 140.

I'd say Khan has the better wins but Brook would have the better win.

As per ts's question, if Brook beat Alexander that win alone is better than any Khan win. It was a triangle theory & you made another to try & support it.

[bojangles1987]

No. Khan beat Kotelnik and Maidana, who are/were about the same level fighter as Alexander.

[kiaba360]

I think Brook would be on equal footing with Khan if he beats Alexander.

[D-MiZe]

As per ts's question, if Brook beat Alexander that win alone is better than any Khan win. It was a triangle theory & you made another to try & support it.

You're missing the point.

If Kotelnik was fairly given the result, he would've ranked higher as a 140lber than Alexander. How good would that win look for Khan?

[dan_cov]

Yes an Alexander win is better than anything on Khans resume.

[boliodogs]

Khan's best win is Maidana and Alexander beat Maidana not that long ago. Alexander is a champion at 147 so a win over him is better than Khan's wins over Judah or Maidana.

[Rome-By-Ko]

No. Khan beat Kotelnik and Maidana, who are/were about the same level fighter as Alexander.

Not as far as accomplishment they are not on the same level..Alexander is a unified Champ and a two div Champ bro..Maidana I still don't even think has won an official Championship and Kottie never unified..I would have to give the edge to Alexander over both fighters...

[NearHypnos]

Alexander has fought the better fighters... So a win by Kel and its better than Kahns. Alexander has a "win" over Matthysse, KOd urango, and dominated Maidana. Kel would have the better win...