Is a win for kell brook better than any of khans wins?

[Juof]

Lets say kell beats alexander would that win be better than khans?

[baya]

I think so, yes. Khans best win was ......... Maidana?

[F!x]

Alexander quit against Bradley and some people thought he lost to Kotelnik (who Khan beat pretty easily).. Alexander isn't a particularly great opponent, but he looks better at 147. If Kell beats him it's a good win for sure, about the same as Khan beating Malignaggi but Khan's resume would still be superior to Brook's at this stage.

[D-MiZe]

Unofficially, Kotelnik beat Alexander.

[Outwest Exp 355]

It depends on how he beats Devon. If he dominates the fight and wins convincingly than hes on his way to becoming a player in the WW division. If he wins a stinker than obviously there will still be question marks.

[Bushbaby]

Yes, if Brook beats Devon it's better than any W Khan owns.

[Bushbaby]

Alexander quit against Bradley and some people thought he lost to Kotelnik (who Khan beat pretty easily).. Alexander isn't a particularly great opponent, but he looks better at 147. If Kell beats him it's a good win for sure, about the same as Khan beating Malignaggi but Khan's resume would still be superior to Brook's at this stage.

Triangle theories, can I try?? Lets see, so Khan almost slept vs Maidana who Alexander dominated, how's that?? Your turn.

[D-MiZe]

Triangle theories, can I try?? Lets see, so Khan almost slept vs Maidana who Alexander dominated, how's that?? Your turn.

If Kotelnik was given a fair shake in his fight with Alexander, he'd be Khan's biggest win. It's not about who only just won or who dominated, it's who won and who lost. No triangle theory, it's all about levels and Alexander would've been ranked below Kotelnik at 140.

I'd say Khan has the better wins but Brook would have the better win.

[-Kev-]

Equal to Kotelnyk IMO.

[-Kev-]

Khan has fought the better fighters from a very young age though, so it's understandable that he is not undefeated.

Prescott, Kotelnyk, Malignaggi, Maidana, Judah, Peterson, Garcia.

Earl, Gomez, Limond were about as good a win as Brook's current best win over Carson Jones IMHO.