Jose Luis Castillo VS Floyd Mayweather I, Who really won??

[TheRichCoward]

Mayweather won the first 5 rounds clearly, and lost the seven last rounds, CLEARLY. Only die hard Floyd nerds on this website will tell you he won with a straight face, in a fight where he was outlanded and had the lower landing percentage. He lost, but there was no way in hell the judges were going to give the fight to some migrant who had no star appeal, and couldn't speak a lick of English. Obviously.

[The Big Dunn]

You are seeking to ignore the fact that Castillo outworked Floyd.

Like I said, Floyd swept the 1-4 easily. Then Castillo took over the middle rounds and finished the fight later on.


Castillo won the later rounds clearer than Floyd. Let's not forget that 10-8 round Floyd had for using his veteran tactic elbow.

No I'm not. I'm just reminding you outworked is a relative term in a sport that winning is determined by rounds won or ko's.

I can outwork you in total, like Castillo did floyd, and lose more rounds and thus the fight. I can outwork you and get ktfo with one punch.

[daggum]

the reason floyd rematched castillo was yes because a lot of people thought he lost but also because hbo wanted him to fight stevie johnston(a slick southpaw who had 2 razor close fights with castillo) floyd was like hmmm slow face first brawler or slick southpaw...rematch!

Arum said. "It's like talking to the wall. I said 'Fight Stevie Johnston.' Floyd said, 'I don't want to fight him. He's a bum.' " then he fought phillip ndou and victoriano sosa....lol

[pasawayako]

Castillo won clear as day.

[Beercules]

No I'm not. I'm just reminding you outworked is a relative term in a sport that winning is determined by rounds won or ko's.

I can outwork you in total, like Castillo did floyd, and lose more rounds and thus the fight. I can outwork you and get ktfo with one punch.

Castillo outworked Floyd in more rounds. 7-4 and Floyd had a 10-8 round.



And then you look at the final Compubox numbers and see Castillo outworked Floyd over the course of 12 rounds, then what? Floyd jabbed more?


C'mon man.

[The Big Dunn]

Castillo outworked Floyd in more rounds. 7-4 and Floyd had a 10-8 round.



And then you look at the final Compubox numbers and see Castillo outworked Floyd over the course of 12 rounds, then what? Floyd jabbed more?


C'mon man.

Not the jabs don't count crap that d4th floated.

Respectfully, if you score the fight using your own scoring system then it's invalid. Jabs are punches and according to the rules judges use, they count.

You don't have to like it.

[Beercules]

Not the jabs don't count crap that d4th floated.

Respectfully, if you score the fight using your own scoring system then it's invalid. Jabs are punches and according to the rules judges use, they count.

You don't have to like it.

So why didn't Dawson win against that farmer Karpency? He landed 100000000 jabs.

[damit305]

the reason floyd rematched castillo was yes because a lot of people thought he lost but also because hbo wanted him to fight stevie johnston(a slick southpaw who had 2 razor close fights with castillo) floyd was like hmmm slow face first brawler or slick southpaw...rematch!

Arum said. "It's like talking to the wall. I said 'Fight Stevie Johnston.' Floyd said, 'I don't want to fight him. He's a bum.' " then he fought phillip ndou and victoriano sosa....lol

No Way! Seems circumstantial.

[rambov]

Why did he need a rematch if (his fans) think he won clearly?


Same with Maidana. What happened?

Because of this thread. Did not matter to him if his fans thought that he won..he wanted to show the world that it was not a fluke.

[Beercules]

Because of this thread. Did not matter to him if his fans thought that he won..he wanted to show the world that it was not a fluke.

Please elaborate