Jose Luis Castillo VS Floyd Mayweather I, Who really won??

[The Big Dunn]

So if fighter A lands more power punches than fighter B in certain rounds, thus winning the rounds fighter A should win the fight? Because he threw some jabs?

Floyd wasn't even his slick usual self.

Or if we get into a fight and I land 100+ power punches on you, I shouldn't win the fight?

There are rules for how judges are required to score fights. You can make up any scenario you wish. That isn't how judges do it.

The bottom line is using compubox total punches to decide who won is wrong. Period. Had you used it to score individual rounds, then you'd have a valid argument.

We get it, you hate Floyd and want him to have a loss. Cool. At least be smart enough and have enough integrity that you use compubox the right way.

[Beercules]

Round 11 was 10-8 floyd, plus floyd won the 12th..

Floyd won the first 4, castillo didn't sweep 5,6,7

Do the math

Castillo won 5,6,7 close but clear.


Round 10 Floyd lost the round and was deducted a point. 10-8 round.

I will double check round 10

[Beercules]

There are rules for how judges are required to score fights. You can make up any scenario you wish. That isn't how judges do it.

The bottom line is using compubox total punches to decide who won is wrong. Period. Had you used it to score individual rounds, then you'd have a valid argument.

We get it, you hate Floyd and want him to have a loss. Cool. At least be smart enough and have enough integrity that you use compubox the right way.

Show me the Compubox for individual rounds I can't find it.

http://www.badlefthook.com/2009/9/18/1034564/classic-round-by-round-jose-luis

[arraamis]

Did I force you to click this thread? I bumped it because I was dis*****g with another user earlier.

I actually clicked the link to berate the idiots that constantly raise the Castillo fight to prove their idiotic points.

And in actuality, you bumped it to openly display your inability to accept reality. No matter how perverse the argument, or how absurd, it cannot erase the opinion of those who really count .... And that is the judges. Not the abundance of idiots with a agenda, nor morons that find it difficult to grasp basic concepts involved with scoring a fight.

You guys try to employ the psycho method of "Repeating a lie often enough and folks will believe" but that doesn't work on the mentally stable. A moron will believe and defend anything that suits his warped mentality. And there is plenty of mental warpage involved with those who contest the decision rendered.

Guess the percentage of non-Floyd fans that constantly raise the Castillo I fight to prove their silly argument.

Whether you can accept it or not .... Reality is a bitch!!!!

[Beercules]

Dunn are you implying that Compubox shouldn't be used to see who won a fight? If you are then you're a hypocrite because I've seen you cite it a couple of times.

[Thickback]

Margarito and Pacquiao fans: Floyd clearly lost, not a close fight.

Floyd's fans: Floyd clearly won.

Boxing fans: Floyd clearly won.

This.................

[HeGotPacProblem]

This.................

Hard to see how the fight was clearly won by either one. Was close.

[The Big Dunn]

Show me the Compubox for individual rounds I can't find it.


http://www.badlefthook.com/2009/9/18...ound-jose-luis

Neither can I. So until you do its probably best you avoid using total punch compubox stats to decide who won fight.

I'm sure they have them at some point during the fight and you will see them as you rewatch fight.

We can agree to disagree who won, just don't sink to the depths that noobs and complete and utter pole smokers do on their daily hate floyd parade.

The total punch count shows that Castillo was very active during the fight. What it doesn't tell you is the points of the fight it took place.

[Beercules]

I actually clicked the link to berate the idiots that constantly raise the Castillo fight to prove their idiotic points.

And in actuality, you bumped it to openly display your inability to accept reality. No matter how perverse the argument, or how absurd, it cannot erase the opinion of those who really count .... And that is the judges. Not the abundance of idiots with a agenda, nor morons that find it difficult to grasp basic concepts involved with scoring a fight.

You guys try to employ the psycho method of "Repeating a lie often enough and folks will believe" but that doesn't work on the mentally stable. A moron will believe and defend anything that suits his warped mentality. And there is plenty of mental warpage involved with those who contest the decision rendered.
h
Guess the percentage of non-Floyd fans that constantly raise the Castillo I fight to prove their silly argument.

Whether you can accept it or not .... Reality is a bitch!!!!

You didn't have to click this thread.


Floyd was out landed by 100+ power punches, that's reality. Obviously you can't deal with it.



Edit: so you're telling me there have never been unfair decisions in boxing? So because the judges called a fight one way, that fighter is the one who actually won the fight in the ring?

[Beercules]

Neither can I. So until you do its probably best you avoid using total punch compubox stats to decide who won fight.

I'm sure they have them at some point during the fight and you will see them as you rewatch fight.

We can agree to disagree who won, just don't sink to the depths that noobs and complete and utter pole smokers do on their daily hate floyd parade.

The total punch count shows that Castillo was very active during the fight. What it doesn't tell you is the points of the fight it took place.

So you can't find the round by round Compubox numbers; but expect me to find it?


Not everyone on that poll "hates" Floyd. He lost the fight and that's it.