Jose Luis Castillo VS Floyd Mayweather I, Who really won??

[deathofaclown]

I thought Floyd won by a round or two. I could see why people could have it a draw but that's generous in my eyes. I really don't see how you can give Castillo 6 rounds, never mind 7 or more for the win.

And no, i'm not a big Floyd fan. Just called it how is see it. He is an undefeated fighter. This probably being the closest fight in a 49 fight career.

[The Problem Child]

I have seen it 13 times now, and I have Castilo winning all 13 times by 3-4 rounds. Floyd also lost the first one against Maidana, the second one is even debatable. He also lost against Oscar, though a much closer fight.

[McNulty]

Jesus christ.Floyd won the first 5 rounds and won the championship rounds...Floyd won a close fight man get over it..

Agreed.

This was my scorecard and I just watched it 2-3 days ago.

Mayweather
1, 2 (10-8 for legit kd cuz if you trip over your own legs after getting tagged thats a knockdown), 3, 4, 5, 10 (-1 point)

Castillo
6, 7, 8 (-1 point), 9, 11, 12

TOTAL
114-113 Mayweather

[Johnny2x2x]

It was 5-0 after 5 and Floyd clearly won 2-3 more rounds. 115-111.

[DuckAdonis]

Had it 113-113 but it could've went 114-112 for either fighter. People who say it was a robbery are biased. Mayweather cleared it up with the rematch tho

[DuckAdonis]

I have seen it 13 times now, and I have Castilo winning all 13 times by 3-4 rounds. Floyd also lost the first one against Maidana, the second one is even debatable. He also lost against Oscar, though a much closer fight.

Yeah you dont know **** about boxing if you think he lost against Maidana and Oscar

[TonyGe]

I just finished watching it. Very close fight. I had Castillo slightly ahead or a draw. Very entertaining fight. The first thing that came to mind was Duran would have slaughtered either one if these two guys.