Comments Thread For: Kellerman: Donaire Creeping up on Pacquiao's P4P Rank

[FeFist]

I already have Donaire ahead of Pacquiao p4p.

[puga]

I don't know how any body could have nonito in the top 5. I mean he fought A prospect coming off a KO loss in WV2. than nonito beat little narvares, than goes life and death with no name jeff mathebulu. now he beat an old nishi who before this fight he went life and death with old as hell marquez. Beating those opponents doesn't Warrant being in the top 5 p4p imo

first of all vasquez was no prospect , he's an ex champ ..2nd , he did'nt go life and death with narvaez, it was onesided fight but boring ..3rd, mathebula was a champion ..who's your top 5?

[J-Smooth]

first of all vasquez was no prospect , he's an ex champ ..2nd , he did'nt go life and death with narvaez, it was onesided fight but boring ..3rd, mathebula was a champion ..who's your top 5?

lol WV2 was a prospect who didn't beat anybody before he lost to arce...and I didn't say he went life and death with little narvarez I said he went life and death with no name jeff mathebulu


my top 5

mayweather
ward
pac
jmm
martinez

[puga]

lol WV2 was a prospect who didn't beat anybody before he lost to arce...and I didn't say he went life and death with little narvarez I said he went life and death with no name jeff mathebulu


my top 5

mayweather
ward
pac
jmm
martinez

who has jmm beaten to deserve it more than nonito? and why is martinez higher than him when he did'nt beat better fighters than nonito?

[J-Smooth]

who has jmm beaten to deserve it more than nonito? and why is martinez higher than him when he did'nt beat better fighters than nonito?

many people believe jmm beat the p4p king in manny pac thats why I got him in the top 5

and sergio had good win over macklin who was coming off a win against felix sturm also win over middleweight monster jcc jr who was coming off a ko of top 10 andy lee

[richardt]

[QUOTE=tiko123;12604495]Martirosyan vs Austin Trout - Full fight![/U][/B]Man, Vanes beat a LOT of guys who went on to become world champs!

[puga]

manny people believe jmm beat the p4p king in manny pac thats why I got him in the top 5

and sergio had good win over macklin who was coming off a win against felix sturm also win over middleweight monster jcc jr who was coming off a ko of top 10 andy lee

the fight was close and many people thought pac won too and officially won..you cant be a p4p over a fantasy win

macklin = mathebula ( he arguably beat caba just like macklin aruably beat strum) but unlike macklin , mathbula has been a champ beating the champ...and there is no way chavez the better win than nishioka..not to mention sergio almost got KTFO..

[NEETzsche]

the fight was close and many people thought pac won too and officially won..you cant be a p4p over a fantasy win

so i suppose you rank bradley above pacquiao, then?

[puga]

so i suppose you rank bradley above pacquiao, then?

you think that fight was close?

[Bring It On]

I'm probably considered a ******* by some (lol) but I agree.

Unless Pac really surprises me against JMM I'd agree with that. Donaire and Floyd would be top2, Ward 3rd.

Pac is pretty much done IMO.