Comments Thread For: Kellerman: Donaire Creeping up on Pacquiao's P4P Rank

[J-Smooth]

the fight was close and many people thought pac won too and officially won..you cant be a p4p over a fantasy win

macklin = mathebula ( he arguably beat caba just like macklin aruably beat strum) but unlike macklin , mathbula has been a champ beating the champ...and there is no way chavez the better win than nishioka..not to mention sergio almost got KTFO..

alright then lets count that bradley win over pac

and caba wasn't that good dude lost jason litzua...so mathebulu "beating" him I don't count to highly

and nishi is old as *** dude went life and death with old marquez

[lightweight12]

Uhh yeah and arum came out with sum bs fighter for donaire next. My honest opinion Nishioka did better after being dropped in the 6th ten years earlier the fight would have been different. Id LOVE to see Donaire against mares I'm high on abner and feel he has a good chance of beating Donaire but hey will Bob make that fight? Nah cuz abner is with gbp

[puga]

alright then lets count that bradley win over pac

and caba wasn't that good dude lost jason litzua...so mathebulu "beating" him I don't count to highly

and nishi is old as *** dude went life and death with old marquez

you cant coz that fight was not close unlike the pac vs jmm fights..and i dont care where you rate pac right now...this is about nonito

say what you want about caba but he was a p4p fighter at one point unlike sturm..and mathebula beat a champion unlike macklin...

youre just descriditing everything to whatever fits you but sorry nishi was still the best at the division and nonito stopped him and thats better than anything jmm or martinez have done lately

[NearHypnos]

I'm probably considered a ******* by some (lol) but I agree.

Unless Pac really surprises me against JMM I'd agree with that. Donaire and Floyd would be top2, Ward 3rd.

Pac is pretty much done IMO.

Donaire over Ward? >__>... Lol. I personally have Ward, Floyd, and Martinez all ahead of Pac. Maybe even Donaire. Pac is definitely behind the main 3 guys right now (Martinez floyd and ward)...and even if he DOES beat Marquez it changes nothing. His career is in stasis slowly slipping away. Donaire would have surpassed one of the three had their performances not been so impressive against much bigger guys.

[DoktorSleepless]

Max is obsessed with p4p lists. It annoys the hell out of me. Leave p4p wanking out of the broadcasts, please.

[J-Smooth]

you cant coz that fight was not close unlike the pac vs jmm fights..and i dont care where you rate pac right now...this is about nonito

say what you want about caba but he was a p4p fighter at one point unlike sturm..and mathebula beat a champion unlike macklin...

youre just descriditing everything to whatever fits you but sorry nishi was still the best at the division and nonito stopped him and thats better than anything jmm or martinez have done lately

I just don't think nonito is top 5 dude is a good fighter but not top 5 imo

and nishi is not the best in the division imo

this is all opinions you have yours I have mine

[puga]

I just don't think nonito is top 5 dude is a good fighter but not top 5 imo

and nishi is not the best in the division imo

this is all opinions you have yours I have mine

all good but you failed to back your p4p list up with solid reasons.. and now nishi was not the best? lol jesus

[WESS]

And you don't even have the balls to say that you agree or disagree with this and are trying to use it as some sort of argument. ***ing LAME.

Looks like the number 1 Drama Queeen Pac hater is on the Rag. Pac is in the top 5 and nothing you can do about it except cry like a Twit which you are damn good at. Man you are desparate when it comes to Pac.

hahahhahaha pac-tarts holding it down. How cute...

[J-Smooth]

all good but you failed to back your p4p list up with solid reasons.. and now nishi was not the best? lol jesus

I backed up my reasons pretty good imo

and no nishi is not the best imo

[WESS]

P4P:
1. Ward
2. Martinez
3. Mayweather
4. JMM
5. Donaire
6. Pac
7. W. Klit
8. Froch
9. Cotto
10. Bradley

_____________________