Comments Thread For: Dre Day: BoxingScene.com's Pound for Pound Update

[KING MEAT]

S.o.g..................

lol. awesome name dude


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[UTEP]

1. Mayweather 2. Marquez 3. Maravilla 4. Ward 5. Pac. That should be the official top 5 in IMO. Andre Ward is super talented but he's not a multi division champ like the other fighters, 168 isn't even 1 of the original 8 divisions lol. If he steps up to 175 and unifies then you could definitely make the argument for # 1 but until then he's just a great 1 division champ.

[HOLLYW00]

This list has really been influenced by recent performance.. I don't know why Cotto is even on this list.. Because he gave Floyd a bloody nose? Marquez.. because he dominated Pac? What's going on here.

[shade darkar]

Number's 1-3 are interchangeable with Ward, Mayweather and Martinez.

What is Pacquiao doing at #2, what is Moreno doing so high up there, he's not even a top 10 P4P fighter IMO. Cotto lost his last fight, what is he doing at #9 in front of Wladimir Klitschko?

Instead of Cotto or Moreno, it should be Bradley and Vitali Klitschko.

this is what makes me laugh. cotto >>>>>>>>> klitschkos. sure cotto lost his last fight, he was fighting floyd fcuking mayweather. who doesnt lose to that guy? the klitschkos win because they are fighting bums. charr? mormeck?

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

I wouldnt rank Pac higher than Floyd, Martinez, or JMM at best Pac is Number 5.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

1. Ward
2. Mayweather Jr
3. Martinez
4. JMM
5. Pacquiao

[-Kev-]

I wouldnt rank Pac higher than Floyd, Martinez, JMM or Martinez at best Pac is Number 5.

Been saying Pacquiao is barely #5 since last year.

[-Kev-]

this is what makes me laugh. cotto >>>>>>>>> klitschkos. sure cotto lost his last fight, he was fighting floyd fcuking mayweather. who doesnt lose to that guy? the klitschkos win because they are fighting bums. charr? mormeck?

Wladimir Klitschko is better than Miguel Cotto P4P. Wlad is a top 5 P4P fighter. Ward, Mayweather, Martinez, Marquez, Wlad/Pacquiao.

[MurkaMan]

Pretty good list. Can't have Mayweather 1-2 because of his inactivity. If he fought more he would be there. I would probably put Wlad higher...

Inactivity is a lame excuse. Boxing is not seasonal. These guys fight on their own time, and after dominating for 16 yrs straight without an L, being 34, he deserves to fight randomly when he wants. P4P is about fighting top opponents, and putting on good showings. Floyd flopped against Cotto, but Pac loss twice in a row. Well technically, he looked HORRIBLE against JMM while still winning. He loses points for performing bad. But he straight up loss to Brad. Martinez walked down a cruiserweight, toe to toe in some sequences, and didnt get touched. Combination punching, excitement, trading, inside fighting, heart. PERFECT showing by Martinez, he was very aggressive against Chavez who was coming off a TKO Victory of Andy, in which Sergio was accused of ducking. Ward is #1, then Martinez is 2, then Floyd, then Pac. Floyd looked bad against Cotto, and Sergio and Ward straight dominated their opponents, and made excitement. Pac is basically washed up, coming off losses, and horrible performances. He gets number 4.

[Bushbaby]

1. Ward
2. Mayweather Jr
3. Martinez
4. JMM
5. Pacquiao

Totally agree with the top 4. I believe you're just being nice with #5,lol!!