Comments Thread For: Dre Day: BoxingScene.com's Pound for Pound Update

[Larry the boss]

ward
floyd
martinez
donaire
bradley

[HOLLYW00]

1. Mayweather 2. Marquez 3. Maravilla 4. Ward 5. Pac. That should be the official top 5 in IMO. Andre Ward is super talented but he's not a multi division champ like the other fighters, 168 isn't even 1 of the original 8 divisions lol. If he steps up to 175 and unifies then you could definitely make the argument for # 1 but until then he's just a great 1 division champ.

Your order is so horrible.. and your reason makes you ******ed.

[shade darkar]

Wladimir Klitschko is better than Miguel Cotto P4P. Wlad is a top 5 P4P fighter. Ward, Mayweather, Martinez, Marquez, Wlad/Pacquiao.

completely disagree. the klitschkos have barely had a career defining fight due to pathetic quality of fighters in their division. cotto is a 3 weight world champion.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Totally agree with the top 4. I believe you're just being nice with #5,lol!!

He could even be as low as 6 depending on how you feel about Froch and Wlad.

[Larry the boss]

I dont know why people rate Jmm so highly to be honest outside of close fights with Manny who has he even fought recently worth mentioning?

[tonyjones]

What a fking ******ed list how can floyd not be number 1 hes the best fighter in the game proves it every time he steps in the ring.ward is a top class fighter but hisn chad dawson win is being so overhyped dawson was drained no doubt.pacquaio has clearly slipped not a chance he's no 2...


I cant stand these idiots overeacting to every win/loss a fighter has

[UTEP]

Your order is so horrible.. and your reason makes you ******ed.

wow that post had a lot of depth to it, care to explain or you just talking out your dumb ass like you usually do?

[shade darkar]

I dont know why people rate Jmm so highly to be honest outside of close fights with Manny who has he even fought recently worth mentioning?

watch him fight and that might answer your question. skill set alone is quality.

[Larry the boss]

watch him fight and that might answer your question. skill set alone is quality.

watch him fight???like ive never seen the guy fight..but he hasnt beat anyone worthy for him to be top 5 p4p,he just hasnt,Bradley has better wins then him lately and so does Martinez and Donaire.so he gave Manny some close fights what else has he done lately??beat shut out by Floyd and beat some bum at 140 in a rigged fight??then another dude at 140 for a interim belt?

[Shonoluv]

joke list

Once again a list that is a popularity contest, 2 in the top four coming off loses.

1. Mayweather
2. Ward
3. Vladimir K
4. Sergio Martinez
5. Moreno
6. Vitali K
7. Nishioka
8. Donaire
9. Cotto
10. Danny Garcia