Who beats a Prime 168 Roy?

[Barn]

Harry Greb.

lol...................

[Barn]

This guy and Thomas Hearns are my two picks.

Tommy at 168?

Really?

[Barn]

At 168 Robinson loses a decision wide...

Not his prime weight... nowhere near.

[sdcluser]

But we're debating Prime FOR Prime, right?

The 168lb, 25yr old Roy Jones Jr right?



Prime RJ would be the most difficult fight to come out with a win for SRR... ESPECIALLY at 168lbs.

That's right. Move like a featherweight and punch like a HW.

[djtmal]

But we're debating Prime FOR Prime, right?

The 168lb, 25yr old Roy Jones Jr right?

And it doesnt matter who is the originator, those that originate are not always the best at it.

Michael Jacksons dance moves are based on James Brown... Is James Brown a better dancer than MJ?


Prime RJ would be the most difficult fight to come out with a win for SRR... ESPECIALLY at 168lbs.

reed, we talking about the originator, AND the best, because as you pointed out, of his record, and we ain't talking about dancin', we talkin' about fightin'

reed, the best fighter, that prime roy jones jr., faced, imo, is james toney @ 168 lbs...reed, i'd take sugar ray robinson, @ 160 lbs., if that is the case...reed, if sugar ray robinson, lands the same left hook, that he landed on gene fullmer, on roy jones, questionable chin, reed, i doubt if roy jones, is gonna keep comin'

[THE REED]

DJ, You doubt it, and I don't.

DJ, If RJ lands the same left hookercut he landed on Montell Griffin I doubt he keeps coming too.

Yes Griffin was at LHW, but Im talkin about the punch itself.

[djtmal]

DJ, You doubt it, and I don't.

DJ, If RJ lands the same left hookercut he landed on Montell Griffin I doubt he keeps coming too.

Yes Griffin was at LHW, but Im talkin about the punch itself.

reed, given that sugar ray robinson, ranks miles ahead of roy jones jr., on the atg list, i'd say that its a good bet that sugar ray robinson, had one of the all-time greatest chins as well as talent in boxing, and takes that punch, and keeps coming..reed, i'd say marvelous marvin hagler, a fighter i've personally seen in my lifetime, takes roy jones jr's punch, and walks him down, spotting roy jones jr. 5 lbs...reed, sugar ray robinson, has never been ko'd in over 200 professional fights, and marvelous marvin hagler, arguably, never left his feet his whole pro career...reed, we know roy jones, was ko'd slightly past prime...

[THE REED]

I cant even read your posts anymore, you say my name after every sentence its irritating the **** out of me.

[WESS]

Bless the Europeans little hearts...

Nobody beats Roy at 168.....

[sammiza567]

rjj goat not even close.