Comments Thread For: No Reward for Robbery: BScene Pound-for-Pound Update

[carts]

so many cry babies in this thread

[BoxingGenius27]

I love it.

not for the fact that Manny is #1, but the fact that it has ruffled the feathers of all of his haters.

Lol only feathers ruffled around here are the Pac fans.

Check the sticky.

[Frogs!]

lmao at all the pac haters who were beaming with pride and joy after he 'lost' on the scorecards against bradley but now are all butthurt after boxingscene unveils it's updated p4p list.

just golden.

[Doc Holliday]

There's no way you can disregard this decision but not Marquez/PAC 3 and other controversial decisions.

Yes you can. If you're biased.

[DE100]

this list is laughable and biased.
regardless of who this writer thinks won the horrible fight.
As a writer you should practice fairness and consistency.
How anyone can have Pacquiao at #1 after his last performances, boggles me. I would love to see his rankings based off of performances..this was certainly based on something else.(when it comes to a certain fighter!)
You dont get rewarded to reamin at the #1 spot because you look like sh!t against a sh!ttier opponent and got robbed..You remain at that spot because you stay dominating viable opponents..something Pac hasnt done in forever!..ehh!!!

Keep in mind you dealing with someone that scored Mayweather vs Cotto 115-113 Mayweather. And had Mayweather losing entering the 10th round.

[Doc Holliday]

I'm dissapointed that manny wasn't moved from the top spot. Everyone will say its because I am a huge floyd fan. Its not. Whether we agree or disagree, manny did lose the fight on 2 of the judges scorecards. I blame bob as do most, for fixing the fight. But we coukd be wrong.

The list is myrhical and a personal opinion so it isn't such a big deal. But it should still be based on official results and not personal disagreements with judges scoring.

I agree. I also had Pac beating Bradley, but you have to have something concrete to base this on, such as official results. Once personal opinion is allowed, everything else goes out the window.

[BoxingGenius27]

Keep in mind you dealing with someone that scored Mayweather vs Cotto 115-113 Mayweather. And had Mayweather losing entering the 10th round.

Who scored Mayweather-Cotto 115-113?

[Primera]

LLMAO

#1 after looking like complete **** and losing the fight?

The pound for pound listings for Bscene doesn't happen to be written by Ronnie Nathanielsz does it?

[Alpha & Omega]

Just another example of the world being up Manny's ass. Good or bad decision, leaving him at #1 P4P is pathetic and ridiculously biased. So if a team gets a bad call that costs them the game in the Super Bowl, do they still get the win and the trophy? Even though they lost on a terribly bad call? This is real bs lol. This bad decision really brought out the truth of what has been going on for years. Manny can just do no wrong, he can lose a fight, refuse blood tests, cheat on taxes, harbor criminals, cheat on his wife, possibly take steroids, yet it does not matter. I never thought I would see a situation where a #1 P4P fighter would lose a fight, regardless of the circumstances and stay at #1. It doesn't matter though, I am over it and so are many other true boxing fans. I respect Manny and think hes a great fighter, but I wish in his next fight someone would just KO him so we can just get over all of this. For something to happen that cannot be argued or denied that he isn't the "God" people think he is. I don't know how you people can look in the mirror and believe your own bull****. Oh well.

The sooner Manny retires the better. For all of us.

[American Dream]

Keep in mind you dealing with someone that scored Mayweather vs Cotto 115-113 Mayweather. And had Mayweather losing entering the 10th round.

this is true. sad, but indeed very true.