Cotto, Castillo, Corrales: Who has the better wins?????

[IronDanHamza]

You wouldn't consider Oscar or JC top 100? I have both top 70.

I don't. Neither.

Especially Calzaghe.

[bojangles1987]

You wouldn't consider Oscar or JC top 100? I have both top 70.

No, I personally don't think either should be top 100, Calzaghe especially. The resume isn't there at all for him. Oscar maybe, but so many of the fights he was in were controversial, and he wasn't dominant enough to overlook his lack of another ATG. That's my opinion anyway, outside of the top 20 or 30 that are probably hard to argue, you can really argue who belongs where.

[bojangles1987]

I don't. Neither.

Especially Calzaghe.

The hell, get out of my head!

[4Corners]

No, I personally don't think either should be top 100, Calzaghe especially. The resume isn't there at all for him. Oscar maybe, but so many of the fights he was in were controversial, and he wasn't dominant enough to overlook his lack of another ATG. That's my opinion anyway, outside of the top 20 or 30 that are probably hard to argue, you can really argue who belongs where.

Where do you rank Floyd???

[bojangles1987]

Where do you rank Floyd???

I don't have a thought out list, I don't know that much, but Floyd belongs somewhere between the 30s and 50s judging by the lists I've seen.

[turbotime]

Jesus. And I'm being harsh.

[Kagami Taiga]

i personally think dlh is in the top 100 but calzaghe??? no way.

[turbotime]

Going by Oscar's record he is a top 100 guy easily IMO

Paez
Leija
Molina
Ruelas
Hernandez
Gonzales
Camacho
Chavez sr (2x)
Rivera
Whitaker
Quartey
Carr
Vargas
Castijello
Mayorga
Sturm

That's a quality list of fighters there. Not to mention Mosley was on the helpers when they fought.

[PrettyBoyRoy 88]

I picked Castillo and thought there would only be 2-3 people more who pick him. Surprised so many picked him, everybody likes to overrate Cotto's resume nowadays.

[4Corners]

Turbo got banned??? What did I miss???

The Cotto stans took the voting over......