who rans higher as a ATG Floyd or Pernell Whitaker

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Corrales Castillo Hatton and Judah were all prime none of them were past it.

Are any of them really HOFers? No....

[IronDanHamza]

your opinion is calling him an atg.someones elses opinion may say cotto,mosley,oscar,hatton are atg's what did Nelson do that was so damn great?

Well, Nelson also beat an ATG in their prime, that was quite great I'd say. Something no one on that list did.

He also dominated the Featherweight and Super Featherweight Divisions.

And if someone's opinion was Cotto, Mosley and Hatton are ATG's then they would be out of touch with reality.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Actually, by some of the Pernell-Chavez logic that is being used in this thread,

Floyd fought Cotto at his prime too.

What physical and mental rapings had Chavez taken prior to fighting Sweet Pea?

I got 2 for Miguel....

[IronDanHamza]

Actually, by some of the Pernell-Chavez logic that is being used in this thread,

Floyd fought Cotto at his prime too.

You can't be serious.

[IronDanHamza]

What I find to be the most hilarious thing is people are actually saying voting for Whitaker is because he's an "old timer"

The guy's era was the 90's. The 90's!

I know the majority of people on here haven't been Boxing fans too long but when the 90's is considered "Old timers" there's a problem.

[Larry the boss]

Well, Nelson also beat an ATG in their prime, that was quite great I'd say. Something no one on that list did.

He also dominated the Featherweight and Super Featherweight Divisions.

And if someone's opinion was Cotto, Mosley and Hatton are ATG's then they would be out of touch with reality.

Mosleys lightweight run>>>Nelsons career.fuck outta here

[Light_Speed]

Floyd Mayweather has arguably not even beat HOF'er in their prime.

Hatton will most likely be inducted in the HOF.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Mosleys lightweight run>>>Nelsons career

You going for a world record of most derps in a day?

[MARKBNLV]

Are any of them really HOFers? No....

Bet you every one i listed makes it in.

[IronDanHamza]

Mosleys lightweight run>>>Nelsons career

You're an idiot, evidently.

Mosley's Lightweight run, that consisted of 1 ranked fighter, is better than Nelson's whole career, a guy who beat an ATG in his prime.

Oh dear.