Who will go down as the greater fighter Juan Manuel Marquez or Tito Trinidad?

[$tate of Mind]

Tito , he would never cheat

Has Marquez been caught cheating?

[Bushidō]

Warquezzzzz

[LeG00N]

Tito , he would never cheat

what about those wraps though.

and link me to an article that states Marquez tested positive

[-Kev-]

Easy to say now, it's JMM. He could further run away with the poll if he beats Bradley. If he beats Bradley it would officially make him a 5-weight champ.


Between the two, Marquez now has the single best win. I would say being a 4 weight champ, Marquez has the accomplishment edge. How many HOF'ers they beat, Marquez has that too, Barrera, Pacquiao, maybe Casamayor if you wanna give him the win over Castillo, Raiymkulov and Freitas, his wins over Corrales, undefeated Seda, undefeated Baek, undefeated Campbell, undefeated Katsidis. I would say Casa is a HOF'er but not first ballot.

[baya]

you gotta go with JMM here. it's really a no-brainer.

but head up, you know that tito decapitates that @ss.

[whitealltrac]

...........

JMM is a good boxer but he is no where near Tito when it comes to a resume.

Tito's fights > JMM fights

Besides a string of fights vs Pac what else did he do???

Tito will be remembered for a long list of tremendous matches, he fought everyone on the top list.

Same as Cotto who even today continues to fight all the top dogs!!

[LeG00N]

JMM is a good boxer but he is no where near Tito when it comes to a resume.

Tito's fights > JMM fights

Besides a string of fights vs Pac what else did he do???

Tito will be remembered for a long list of tremendous matches, he fought everyone on the top list.

Same as Cotto who even today continues to fight all the top dogs!!

Hell yea, Tito beat Joppy and Vargas. Plus he fought the top Dogs

[$coinblatt$]

people overrate Tito because of the number of mediocre WW title defenses. His best win is a robbery against De La ****, Shot to **** coked out Whitaker, Vargas, and Joppy.

[$coinblatt$]

Same as Cotto who even today continues to fight all the top dogs!!

Cotto got his ass whooped by Margarito, Pacquiao and Floyd.

Fighting and beating are 2 different things.

[$tate of Mind]

Easy to say now, it's JMM. He could further run away with the poll if he beats Bradley. If he beats Bradley it would officially make him a 5-weight champ.


Between the two, Marquez now has the single best win. I would say being a 4 weight champ, Marquez has the accomplishment edge. How many HOF'ers they beat, Marquez has that too, Barrera, Pacquiao, maybe Casamayor if you wanna give him the win over Castillo, Raiymkulov and Freitas, his wins over Corrales, undefeated Seda, undefeated Baek, undefeated Campbell, undefeated Katsidis. I would say Casa is a HOF'er but not first ballot.

Does Marquez losing to Bradley change your opinion?