Donaire not a P4P

[arodriguez]

Is Donaire a hype job?

I was not impressed by him this past Saturday and I don’t think he deserves to be in the P4P list.. To me he hasnt proved anything...

Let me know your thoughts ??

[ИATAS]

he's certainly a p4p fighter. Where he should be ranked in the top ten is up for debate, but he's top 10 worthy.

[victorythagr8]

Is Donaire a hype job?

I was not impressed by him this past Saturday and I don’t think he deserves to be in the P4P list.. To me he hasnt proved anything...

Let me know your thoughts ??

But Martinez, bradley and ward does?????

Donaire's resume **** on all three resume and has beaten 2 p4p level fighter.

How is donaire a hype job especially the way he destroyed both darchinyan and montiel.

[FJRod]

he's certainly a p4p fighter. Where he should be ranked in the top ten is up for debate, but he's top 10 worthy.

Def P4P but should not be ahead of Ward and Klit.

[Box Up!]

Is Donaire a hype job?

I was not impressed by him this past Saturday and I don’t think he deserves to be in the P4P list.. To me he hasnt proved anything...

Let me know your thoughts ??

Didn’t you know? On boxing scene one average performance means you’re rubbish? Seriously, that’s a fact, there are no good boxers, they’re all rubbish.

Spend 5 mins on here, you’ll see that’s the truth according to most people who post on this forum.

Manny, terrible.

Floyd, awful.

Donaire, the worst boxer on the planet.

Cotto, a girl.

Etc, etc.

You see if you don’t KO your opponent within ½ second of the 1st Rd then CLEARLY you’re a hype job with no skills at all.

[ИATAS]

Def P4P but should not be ahead of Ward and Klit.

yeah I think Ward should be bumped up to the top 5 and donaire should be at the bottom 5 somewhere.

Should look something like this imo:

1. Floyd
2. Manny
3. Marquez
4. Ward
5. Martinez

I don't know what to say about klitschko. I have no real opinion if he's on the list or not. Some people don't include heavyweights on their list, others do.

[sicko]

2 average fights back to back, I still think he is Top 10 P4P but he should start falling a little, he certainly shouldn't be higher then Ward, JMM or Wlad right now

[FJRod]

yeah I think Ward should be bumped up to the top 5 and donaire should be at the bottom 5 somewhere.

Should look something like this imo:

1. Floyd
2. Manny
3. Marquez
4. Ward
5. Martinez

I don't know what to say about klitschko. I have no real opinion if he's on the list or not. Some people don't include heavyweights on their list, others do.

Agree! although I would still drop Martinez to 6th and Bring up Klit.

[Fetta]

I think Mares and Rigo beat him so for me he is good but not a P4p yet. Same time I don't think Bradley should be on there either.

[ИATAS]

I think Mares and Rigo beat him so for me he is good but not a P4p yet. Same time I don't think Bradley should be on there either.

mares would get wrecked. His style is what Donaire likes.

Guys that are defensive or counter punchers, those are the guys that will give him problems. Which is why Rigondeaux is probably his toughest fight at 122.