Donaire not a P4P

[frosty-g]

this is what happens when you dont follow boxing.

the thing is i've seen both of those guys fight and find it very hard to believe that either could be rated particularly highly at all. especially vic.

[HeroBando]

the thing is i've seen both of those guys fight and find it very hard to believe that either could be rated particularly highly at all. especially vic.

I'm pretty sure Vic wasn't top 10 at the time, he only got ranked post Donaire for his junior bantam unification and beatdown of Arce. Which is what carried Donaire into the p4p list, but he has since justified it.

Montiel was ranked for beating Hasegawa and being a 3 weight champ, but wasn't an established bantam otherwise.

[noStylez]

yeah I think Ward should be bumped up to the top 5 and donaire should be at the bottom 5 somewhere.

Should look something like this imo:

1. Floyd
2. Manny
3. Marquez
4. Ward
5. Martinez

I don't know what to say about klitschko. I have no real opinion if he's on the list or not. Some people don't include heavyweights on their list, others do.

Nice list.

[LeG00N]

he's a P4P fighter but he should definitely be lower than Marquez....

I agree with NATAS list

[Mr. Philadel]

Is Donaire a hype job?

I was not impressed by him this past Saturday and I don’t think he deserves to be in the P4P list.. To me he hasnt proved anything...

Let me know your thoughts ??

you let Larry Merchant pick your brain lol...Flash is legit...don't let that bs Merchant was saying mess with your head.....dude can rumble....he's gonna be at the top for a long time!!