Shane Mosley vs Jose Luis Castillo at lightweight who wins?

[Walt Liquor]

What you think Shane was greater at lightweight than JLC? Really???????

there's just some confusion regarding whether the other poster was talking about career-wise or lw wise.

i guarantee he doesn't think shane has a better lw resume

[TOBYLEE1]

Mosley has always done well with pressure fighters, Shane by KO

[IronDanHamza]

Castillo would probably lose to Mosley at Lightweight.

Doesn't change the fact Castillo is the way greater Lightweight.

[Junior M Weight]

Castillo is the greater at LW, way better career and opposition fought.

These are the only facts we can go by. Giving the benefit of the doubt to jlc.

Castillo > Mosley

[Luilun]

Who wins this fantasy fight.

Castillo, had two reigns as a champ at lightweight, making a total of 5 successful defenses, losing out to Mayweather on a disputed decision and getting stopped by Corrales after putting him down a few times in the round.

Mosley, was dominant at the weight making 8 title defense winning all by KO

Castillo was come forward pressure boxer-brawler worked the body well.

Mosely loved fighting this time a fighter and would damage them with body shots before going upstairs and getting the KO.

Mosley was much the bigger puncher and had the better chin.

So who wins this fantasy fight?

Depends Mosley with or with out EPO cause Mosley the cheat is a dud without it