Shane Mosley vs Jose Luis Castillo at lightweight who wins?

[D4thincarnation]

Who wins this fantasy fight.

Castillo, had two reigns as a champ at lightweight, making a total of 5 successful defenses, losing out to Mayweather on a disputed decision and getting stopped by Corrales after putting him down a few times in the round.

Mosley, was dominant at the weight making 8 title defense winning all by KO

Castillo was come forward pressure boxer-brawler worked the body well.

Mosely loved fighting this time a fighter and would damage them with body shots before going upstairs and getting the KO.

Mosley was much the bigger puncher and had the better chin.

So who wins this fantasy fight?

[DLT]

Mosley dominates him. Bad style matchup for JLC

[LeG00N]

Castillo is still greater @ LW

[SixFootGiant]

My money would be on Shane

[BigStereotype]

Castillo gets hit too much and Mosley carried his power up to welterweight. He was freakishly strong at LW. Mosley could stop him, but KO or no, he definitely wins it.

[-Deal With It-]

Mosley WHILE ON EPO would take a clear, emphatic decision.

Mosley WITHOUT EPO would still take the fight, but it would be a war.

I can say this though, with certainty. If Mosley while @ Lightweight had to face the same fighters that Castillo faced at Lightweight. He would've left the division with 3 or 4 losses at the very least.

[4Corners]

Castillo gave Floyd all he could handle that first fight, and OF COURSE the TS forgot to mention that Floyd rematched him immediately and won convincingly.

I'd bet on Mosley, but Castillo did more at LW, and it depends on if Shane was on PED's of course.

Mosley would win H2H, but I'd rate Castillo higher All-Time than Shane.

Castillo is probably the top LW if his era, and would be one of the top LW in most era's. He was pretty underrated, especially who he had to fight.

[Boxing Bob]

its hard to imagine Castillo winning this fight

[D4thincarnation]

Strange, though quite a few votes have been cast for Castillo, none of the voters have posted to say how they think Castillo would win this fight.

Would be interested in hearing your views.

[EdMon917]

Who wins this fantasy fight.

Castillo, had two reigns as a champ at lightweight, making a total of 5 successful defenses, losing out to Mayweather on a disputed decision and getting stopped by Corrales after putting him down a few times in the round.

Mosley, was dominant at the weight making 8 title defense winning all by KO

Castillo was come forward pressure boxer-brawler worked the body well.

Mosely loved fighting this time a fighter and would damage them with body shots before going upstairs and getting the KO.

Mosley was much the bigger puncher and had the better chin.

So who wins this fantasy fight?

That is why I would pick Mosley. You kind of answered your own question.