who's greater juan manuel marquez or miguel cotto

[LeG00N]

I guess you don't know much about boxing if you don't consider Chris John one of the top fighters in boxing.

I think any expert and unbiased fan doesn't count Margarito's plaster aided W. Cotto has 1 L in his career against the # 2 p4p in a fight in which he went into with no trainer.

But his resume is still better than JMM.

....John is a top fighter? because he fights who again?
his career highlight is getting a home town decision over Marquez.
other that he fights bums in Indonesia


no Cotto doesn't have 1 lose... stop trying to re-write history he got stopped by Margarito. Deal with it.

[ChiRock773]

Ask Manny that question...??

[FJRod]

These kinds of threads separate the Boxing fans from the FAN BOYZ. The Tito vs Marquez thread is a much closer thread but this one is a landslide for Marquez. BTW Tito will ALWAYS be GREATER than Marquez.

[Dempsey-Roll]

JMM by far. I like Cotto, but he can't compare to JMM

[Iceta Lives]

Man Cotto was getting touched up by past prime Judah won a very close decision against a past prime Mosley and lost to fucking Clottey seriously stop overrating the guy he was the top guy in his division for how long? 4months?

Green k my man. Nothing else needs said here.

[Trophyboy23]

I'd have to say JMM

[Cuauhtémoc1520]

These kinds of threads separate the Boxing fans from the FAN BOYZ. The Tito vs Marquez thread is a much closer thread but this one is a landslide for Marquez. BTW Tito will ALWAYS be GREATER than Marquez.

This is one is a joke and JMM > Tito all day everyday.

[.::|ULTIMATE|::.]

Cotto is a good fighter an all but JMM is on another level and frankly it is not even up for real debate.

[Rompeboca]

Let them fight each other. Cotto vs Marquez

[isbj]

Cotto's best wins were a close decision against Mosley and an avenged loss to Margarito who hasn't really amounted to anything since they took away his casts. So what does that tell you?