Marquez arguably beat Pac twice and he's not a legit opponent ?

[johnm is...]

because he doesn't want to make the little sacrifices needed to make 140 lbs ?

or because he wants to be heavier than JMM ? isn't the fight happening at 144 ?

Just say what you mean....

"because he wants the advantage". There's no need to sugar coat it.

[Deevel916]

If Manny's not a welterweight, then why on earth would he insist on fighting Marquez at welterweight?

Too much emphasis is being placed on weigh in weights nowadays.

For this fight, the contracted weigh in weight is 144. JMM isnt being forced to weigh in at 144. He can train the same exact way he would for a LW fight and come in the ring his ususal weight which is anywhere from 142-146. Pac never weighs in at the WW limit. He will weigh in around 145 and weigh 146-147 on fight night.

How is JMM at a weight disadvantage?

[Tiozzo]

Just say what you mean....

"because he wants the advantage". There's no need to sugar coat it.

if Pacquiao blasts Marquez at 144 lbs, don't you think he would do it at 140 lbs regardless?

[johnm is...]

if Pacquiao blasts Marquez at 144 lbs, don't you think he would do it at 140 lbs regardless?

Tough to say. That's the same argument that Mayweather backers get bashed relentlessly for.

[Tiozzo]

To me the best reason to doubt the fight isn't weight because I don't think either guy is really bigger than the other, they are of similar size and there is no range issue.

Age and tread on the tire are the issues to be concerned about regarding JMM as compared to Manny relatively. JMM has been keeping the wagon going but all the way back to the Casamayor fight he was looking a bit worn, now he has taken care of business but has suffered quite a few beatings since that fight and Manny has looked just fine. The real question is where are both men at and does JMM still have it in him to really do what he did previously.

I personally hope JMM has one great fight left in him, but the wheels could fall off the wagon at any time and Manny is the sort of fighter that tends to make wheels fall off~

that's a good point

it is true that even if Marquez has won all of his LW fights, he has taken some punishment, particularly in the brutal first Diaz fight

Marquez is getting older indeed, but still a very capable fighter

his stamina worries me more than his overall athletic condition (timing, speed, etc.)

[Deevel916]

Tough to say. That's the same argument that Mayweather backers get bashed relentlessly for.

Mayweather gets bashed for agreeing to weigh in at 144, failing to make the weight and instead weigh 146, then god knows how much he rehydrated over night since he refused to be weighed on fight night.

[johnm is...]

Too much emphasis is being placed on weigh in weights nowadays.

For this fight, the contracted weigh in weight is 144. JMM isnt being forced to weigh in at 144. He can train the same exact way he would for a LW fight and come in the ring his ususal weight which is anywhere from 142-146. Pac never weighs in at the WW limit. He will weigh in around 145 and weigh 146-147 on fight night.

How is JMM at a weight disadvantage?

I agree with you that to much emphasis is being placed on weight. Timing is the bigger issue.

Anyway, if you don't recognize that Marquez is at a disadvantage here, then there's really no reason to carry on this discussion.

[johnm is...]

Mayweather gets bashed for agreeing to weigh in at 144, failing to make the weight and instead weigh 146, then god knows how much he rehydrated over night since he refused to be weighed on fight night.

Mayweather got bashed for taking the fight. Point. Blank. Period.

[Real King Kong]

I agree with you that to much emphasis is being placed on weight. Timing is the bigger issue.

Anyway, if you don't recognize that Marquez is at a disadvantage here, then there's really no reason to carry on this discussion.

well put...i was wondering how long it would take pac fans to start deluding themselves into thinking these two are picking it up right where they left off. marquez is 38 years old and shop worn...his speed timing and footwork have diminished considerably since the last pac fight. thats what makes his fights more exiting lately...he's ****ing with the type of guys he used to outbox.

[DannYankee]

SImple Pacquiao's transition to tht weight division is been great in d other hand Marquez didnt at all did u not see him fight Mayweather? he will get rolled on by Pac at this weight.