Sergio Martinez vs. Floyd Mayweather: who would win?

[hhs661]

Sergio IMO

[Arma316]

I think Floyd edges Martinez on the cards via decision. Would be a tactical fight.

[dosepulgada]

If Martinez fights Floyd at 154, Martinez will be too dehydrated. Hence Floyd wins hands down.

But if Martinez fights Floyd in MW, then the lead is a lot smaller. There we can see a better fight. But Ill still be for may with a close decision.

[GreatestIam]

Vicious beating much like corrales was dealt with.............

[sdcluser]

At 154, I think Sergio has better shot of winning.

[_original_]

I think it's 50/50 but you kind of have to slightly favor Martinez due to size and power.

If Floyd fought and beat Martinez, would people even be interested in him fighting Pacquiao? I view Martinez as a more dangerous threat.

[Doctor_Tenma]

This fight needs to happen.

[dosepulgada]

This shows that Serg is giving up his legacy just to get a shot of the money on the table. I mean, if Serg wins dehydrated, it will be cool. Its like Ortiz winning against May. But everyone knows that it aint going to happen. So for me, his dream of fighting may or pac, are just annoying. Its like someone is willing sell his legacy to earn bigtime. There are too many great fighters at heavier weights.

This is why I dont believe even by winning against Serg, May should get any props, unless he fights Serg in his own division. And if he wins that, theres no question that pac's lead over him is a lot slimmer during ATG talk.

[Brother Jay]

When you tell me where the hipbone is located & why it is illegal to punch there then come see me.

I don't know if you've ever taken anatomy, but it wouldn't be a bad idea if you thought that punching the hip was a legal shot. Its a dirty shot. Show me someone whose hips are located above the belt line and then come see me.

ANYTHING BELOW THE BELT LINE IS ILLEGAL!!

How long have you been watching boxing?????????

Sheesh.

[SkillspayBills]

I would give Floyd more credit for beating Martinez at 154 than I would for him beating Pac at 147. Martinez is BIG, walking around at 180. Floyd would have to be on his A-game and honestly.......I would expect it to be relatively boring since Floyd aint doing that stand in front of you **** against Martinez.