Prime Oscar vs. Pac Mayweather or Ortiz

[Queen_Leia]

Prime for Prime, how do you see Prime Oscar handling Prime Pacquiao, Mayweather and Ortiz?

[Bushbaby]

Oscar retires the side.

[IronDanHamza]

Mayweather beats him
Pac beats him
Ortiz loses to him

[ModernTalking]

Oscar was a very good fighter in his prime but you have to take into account that he has had some tuff fights. He wasn't alway dominating in some of his fights. He would have the edge due to his size but I wouldn't be surprise if PAC beat him.

[Queen_Leia]

Oscar was a very good fighter in his prime but you have to take into account that he has had some tuff fights. He wasn't alway dominating in some of his fights. He would have the edge due to his size but I wouldn't be surprise if PAC beat him.

Good observation Modern, but how would Ortiz and Mayweather do against Oscar?

[jvsnypes]

I think it depends on who was his trainer. If Mayweather Sr was in his corner, he beats all 3. He was a better fighter imo with Floyd Sr in his corner. His jab and big left hand and foot speed would have been too much for them. I could see him knocking out Ortiz the same way he did Vargas. It would be a war with him and Manny. But I think he would simply outbox Manny in the end. The Mayweather fight would be tactical and close. I just think Oscar in his prime would just stay too busy and win a decision. Hell, he almost won it past his prime against Floyd. Oscar was the truth in his prime. He fought them all.Even though he couldn't win the big ones in his time, he was still a true warrior and a threat.

[ModernTalking]

I think it depends on who was his trainer. If Mayweather Sr was in his corner, he beats all 3. He was a better fighter imo with Floyd Sr in his corner. His jab and big left hand and foot speed would have been too much for them. I could see him knocking out Ortiz the same way he did Vargas. It would be a war with him and Manny. But I think he would simply outbox Manny in the end. The Mayweather fight would be tactical and close. I just think Oscar in his prime would just stay too busy and win a decision. Hell, he almost won it past his prime against Floyd. Oscar was the truth in his prime. He fought them all.Even though he couldn't win the big ones in his time, he was still a true warrior and a threat.

The truth....LOL

During his prime Oscar was great but not the truth. You make it seems like he was destroying everybody in his path. Oscar fought alot of good fighters during his prime but like I said he never seem to dominate them. It was more of a back in forth fight. Is edge to beating Manny has to be his size.

[Jack Napier]

Mayweather beats him
Pac beats him
Ortiz loses to him

^^^^^^^^^^^what he said

[straightleft]

Prime Pac vs prime Oscar if both are the same size Pac will beat him.

[niceyboo3]

Threads like these are the reason for *******s and *****s. We know that Pacman and Floyd were fighting at lighter divisions during Oscars prime. Jesus Christ. Sergio Martinez would beat nonito in his prime...